请选择 进入手机版 | 继续访问电脑版

战列舰

 找回密码
 加入我们

QQ登录

只需一步,快速开始

搜索
查看: 39192|回复: 224

Nathan Okun大口径舰炮穿深表

[复制链接]

中将

四年服役纪念章钻石金双剑金橡叶铁十字勋章荣誉勋章维多利亚十字勋章行政立法委骑士团勋章海武魂旗手TIME TRAVELER终身荣誉会员

发表于 2013-1-11 00:20:04 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式
本帖最后由 seven_nana 于 2014-8-27 10:59 编辑

Nathan Okun大口径舰炮穿深表

原文链接:http://www.navweaps.com/index_nathan/Penetration_index.htm

站内镜像:http://www.zhanliejian.com/navweaps/Penetration_index.htm

本贴主要讨论Nathan Okun穿深表中,各国大口径舰炮的表现。关于中口径舰炮的表现,请移步此帖:Nathan Okun中口径舰炮穿深表



表格解析:下列表格,分别列举了美,日,英,法,德,意六国的较有代表性的战列舰火炮对各国装甲的穿深数据。

第一行数据为射击距离,单位是1,000码;以下数据为对各国装甲的穿深数据,单位是英寸。各国装甲数据中,前四排为垂直装甲穿深,第五排为水平装甲穿深。在穿深数据下方,还有两排数据。一排是落角,单位是度;另一排是着速,单位是英尺/秒。

缩写解析:

Br = 英国
US = 美国
It = 意大利
Ger = 德国
Jp = 日本

PP = 部分穿透
H = 穿孔极限
NL = 海军穿透极限
EFF = 有效穿透极限
Deck = 水平穿深

垂直装甲部分,列举的是有效穿透极限的穿深数据,采用Nathan Okun的FACEHARD程序计算。

垂直装甲的定义:装甲垂直放置,表面平整,硬化层朝外;而非倾斜放置,表面弯曲,硬化层朝内。

部分穿透的定义:对于入射倾角小于45度的情况而言,若射弹前半段侵入了装甲,而后半段未能完成穿透,则称为部分穿透。对于入射倾角大于45度的情况而言,若弹尖与上半段弹体未能完成穿透,而破损残余①的下半段弹体侵入了装甲,则称为部分穿透。
①前提是射弹确实发生破损了。但以如此高落角命中,且已超过了海军穿透极限的炮弹,通常都会发生破损的。

穿孔极限的定义:射弹在装甲表面上冲出一个尺寸与其弹径接近的孔洞,但弹体本身完全穿透装甲的部分,其质量未能达到海军穿透极限的标准。没能达成此类情况的射弹,也依然可以造成有限程度的破坏,通常会局限在受冲击装甲板的背后附近,有可能只会造成震荡冲击效应。

海军穿透极限的定义:在弹体没有破损的情况下,完全穿透装甲的弹体部分须占弹体总质量的100%(不计入风帽与被帽的质量)。若弹体发生破损,则完全穿透装甲的弹体部分须占弹体总质量的80%。此外,海军穿透极限并不关注射弹穿透装甲后产生的后效:即射弹在穿透装甲后,有可能会爆炸,也有可能不会爆炸。

有效穿透极限的定义:在基本保证装药腔完整,弹底栓未启封,引信能够有效工作的前提下,射弹能够达成的最大穿深。对于射弹其余部位的损坏与否不做关注。达成有效穿透极限所需的着速,可能与穿孔极限相同或略高;此外也有可能发生,在给定命中条件下,无论着速如何,均无法产生有效穿透的情况。

对应的的装甲材质:英国为CA,美国为Class A(1935-1943),意大利为Terni生产的KC,德国为KC n/A(1936-1945),日本为VH(1937-1945)

水平装甲部分,采用Nathan Okun的M79APCLC程序计算。原作者表示,对于均质水平装甲的穿深计算,目前尚没有一套系统能够准确量化不同射弹在不同条件下产生的不同效果,该程序已是现有的最佳选择。该程序对英德炮弹的模拟较为精确,对于美日炮弹的模拟则有所偏差。

计算水平穿深时采纳的装甲参数:英国装甲,质量系数1.0,伸长率25%(即NCA);美国装甲,质量系数1.0,伸长率25%(即Class B);意大利装甲,质量系数1.0,伸长率17.1%(即NCV);德国装甲,质量系数1.0,伸长率18%(即Wh);日本装甲,质量系数0.97,伸长率23%(即MNC)。

备注:M79APCLC实际上是用于计算无被帽穿甲弹对均质装甲的穿深数据的,它是以陆军76.2mm尖头无被帽穿甲弹的数据作为基础的。由于该程序无法模拟不同的弹头形状带来的差异,因此无法准确还原实际情况。此外由于此处设定的伸长率存在争议,与实测报告有出入,因此我认为这些水平穿深数据没有多大参考价值。

射弹的数据,射弹全重指的是完整射弹的重量;弹体重量指的是穿甲体本身的重量,不含风帽与被帽的重量。

举例:
美国海军的16英寸(40.64厘米)Mark 8 Mod 6型穿甲弹,重2,700磅(1,225千克)。资料来自海军试验场报告,第3-47号。
被帽:312磅(141.5千克),占总重的11.6%
风帽:32.4磅(14.7千克),占总重的1.2%
装药:40.5磅(18.4千克),占总重的1.5%
弹体(含装药):2,355.6磅(1,068.5千克),占总重的87.2%

美国火炮

16英寸/50倍经 Mark 7型火炮,发射Mark 8 Mod 1 - Mod 5型穿甲弹(1943-44年间使用),射弹全重2,700磅,弹体重2,386.6磅;最大射程42,345码。

Range024681012141618202224262830323436384042
Br PP33.131.429.728.126.625.123.722.421.219.918.81817.116.315.514.61413.312.71211.39.7
Br H----------------------
Br NL--------------------10.18.6
Br EFF29.52826.525.123.722.421.22018.917.516.71615.314.613.81312.511.811.310.7108.4
Br Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.53.84.14.44.85.36.17.2911.61418
US PP37.735.733.83230.328.62725.524.122.721.420.519.518.617.616.715.915.815.114.313.511.5
US H----------------------
US NL--------------------1210.3
US EFF33.631.930.228.62725.524.122.821.520.319.118.317.416.615.714.814.213.512.912.711.910
US Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.53.84.14.44.85.36.17.2911.61418
It PP31.329.728.126.625.223.722.521.22018.917.81716.215.514.713.813.212.61211.310.79.5
It H----------------------
It NL--------------------9.98.5
It EFF27.926.525.123.722.421.22018.917.916.815.915.214.513.813.112.311.811.210.710.19.88.3
It Deck00.430.861.21.72.12.533.43.84.34.64.95.35.86.47.59.212.215.81924.2
Ger PP34.532.73129.427.626.224.823.42220.819.618.817.917.116.215.314.613.913.212.512.310.6
Ger H----------------------
Ger NL-------------------11.210.59
Ger EFF30.829.227.726.224.723.322.120.919.718.617.516.71615.214.413.61312.311.810.910.48.8
Ger Deck00.420.841.21.62.12.52.93.33.74.24.54.85.25.76.37.38.911.715.118.223.3
Jp PP39.937.835.933.932.130.328.627.125.524.122.721.720.719.718.717.716.91615.314.514.312.2
Jp H----------------------
Jp NL--------------------11.69.9
Jp EFF33.932.230.528.827.225.724.32321.720.519.318.417.616.815.91514.313.61312.311.59.7
Jp Deck00.380.761.11.51.92.22.633.43.84.14.44.75.25.76.67.89.912.815.519.8
Descent0123.144.45.77.59.311.21314.917.520.222.925.628.331.735.138.54245.553.3
Velocity2500241223242238215620742007194018731806174017051670163616011567156215571574159016071686

16英寸/50倍经 Mark 7型火炮,发射Mark 8 Mod 6 - Mod 8型穿甲弹(1945-92年间使用),射弹全重2,700磅,弹体重2,352.5磅;最大射程42,345码。

Range024681012141618202224262830323436384042
Br PP----------------15.514.714.113.312.610.8
Br H36.734.93331.229.527.926.424.923.522.220.92019.118.217.216.315.314.213.212.1--
Br NL---------------------9.6
Br EFF32.831.129.527.926.324.823.522.22119.818.617.81716.215.314.513.913.112.611.911.29.5
Br Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.53.84.14.44.85.36.17.2911.61418
US PP----------------17.716.81615.214.212.3
US H41.839.737.635.633.631.73028.426.825.323.822.821.720.719.618.517.516.11513.8--
US NL---------------------11
US EFF37.335.433.531.73028.326.825.323.922.521.220.319.418.417.516.515.81514.313.512.810.9
US Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.53.84.14.44.85.36.17.2911.61418
It PP----------------14.71413.312.611.910.2
It H34.83331.329.62826.42523.622.32119.818.91817.216.315.414.513.412.511.5--
It NL---------------------9.5
It EFF3129.427.926.424.923.522.32119.918.717.616.916.115.314.513.713.112.411.911.210.69.4
It Deck00.430.861.21.72.12.533.43.84.34.64.95.35.86.47.59.212.215.81924.2
Ger PP----------------16.215.414.713.913.111.3
Ger H38.436.434.532.630.829.127.52624.623.121.820.919.91918171614.813.812.7--
Ger NL----------------------
Ger EFF34.232.530.829.127.525.924.623.221.920.619.418.417.716.91615.114.513.713.112.411.710
Ger Deck00.420.841.21.62.12.52.93.33.74.24.54.85.25.76.37.38.911.715.118.223.3
Jp PP----------------18.817.81716.115.213
Jp H44.342.139.937.735.633.631.830.128.426.925.224.12321.920.819.618.416.815.514.1--
Jp NL---------------------11.1
Jp EFF37.735.733.93230.327.62725.624.122.721.420.519.518.617.616.715.915.114.413.712.911
Jp Deck00.380.761.11.51.92.22.633.43.84.14.44.75.25.76.67.89.912.815.519.8
Descent0123.144.45.77.59.311.21314.917.520.222.925.628.331.735.138.54245.553.3
Velocity2500241223242238215620742007194018731806174017051670163616011567156215571574159016071686

16英寸/45倍经 Mark 6型火炮,发射Mark 8 Mod 1 - Mod 5型穿甲弹(1939-44年间使用),射弹全重2,700磅,弹体重2,386.6磅;最大射程36,900码。

Range024681012141618202224262830323436
Br PP29.928.326.725.223.822.321.119.918.817.716.615.915.224.413.612.81211.210.4
Br H----------- -------
Br NL----------------10.7109.3
Br EFF26.625.223.822.521.219.918.817.816.715.814.814.213.512.812.111.410.69.78.8
Br Deck00.360.7211.41.82.12.52.83.23.644.555.76.58.411.313.8
US PP3432.230.428.727.125.42422.721.420.11918.117.316.415.514.614.313.312.4
US H-------------------
US NL----------------12.211.410.6
US EFF30.328.727.225.624.122.721.420.219.11816.916.215.414.613.81312.11110
US Deck00.360.7211.41.82.12.52.83.23.644.555.76.58.411.313.8
It PP28.326.825.323.922.521.22018.917.816.715.715.114.413.612.912.111.410.610.2
It H-------------------
It NL----------------10.69.89.1
It EFF25.223.922.621.320.118.917.816.815.814.91413.412.812.111.510.810.19.28.7
It Deck00.440.881.31.72.22.633.53.94.44.85.46.178.111.215.418.7
Ger PP31.229.527.926.324.823.32220.819.618.517.416.615.91514.213.412.611.710.9
Ger H-------------------
Ger NL----------------11.210.49.7
Ger EFF27.826.324.923.522.120.819.618.517.516.515.514.814.113.412.711.911.110.19.2
Ger Deck00.430.861.21.72.12.533.43.84.34.75.25.96.87.910.814.817.9
Jp PP36.134.132.330.428.72725.52422.621.320.119.218.317.416.415.414.513.512.6
Jp H-------------------
Jp NL----------------12.311.510.7
Jp EFF30.62927.425.924.422.921.620.419.218.117.116.315.614.813.913.112.211.110.1
Jp Deck00.390.781.11.51.92.32.73.13.53.94.34.85.46.179.212.515.2
Descent01.42.74.15.46.8911.213.515.717.921.124.327.630.83438.442.847.2
Velocity2300222021402060198019001841178217221663160415811558153615131490150615231539

16英寸/45倍经 Mark 6型火炮,发射Mark 8 Mod 6 - Mod 8型穿甲弹(1945-47年间使用),射弹全重2,700磅,弹体重2,352.5磅;最大射程36,900码。

Range024681012141618202224262830323436
Br PP--------------15.114.213.412.411.6
Br H33.231.429.72826.424.823.52220.819.618.517.716.9161513.812.511.3-
Br NL-------------------
Br EFF29.62826.52523.522.120.919.718.617.516.515.815.114.313.512.711.911.110.3
Br Deck00.360.7211.41.82.12.52.83.23.644.555.76.58.411.313.8
US PP--------------17.216.215.214.213.2
US H37.835.833.831.930.128.326.725.223.722.421.120.219.218.217.115.714.312.8-
US NL-------------------
US EFF33.731.930.228.526.825.223.822.521.22018.81817.116.215.314.413.612.611.7
US Deck00.360.7211.41.82.12.52.83.23.644.555.76.58.411.313.8
It PP--------------14.91413.212.211.4
It H32.730.929.227.62624.423.121.820.519.318.217.416.615.714.813.512月3日11.1-
It NL-------------------
It EFF29.127.626.124.623.221.820.619.418.317.216.215.514.81413.312.511.710.910.1
It Deck00.440.881.31.72.22.633.53.94.44.85.46.178.111.215.418.7
Ger PP--------------15.814.8141312.1
Ger H34.732.83129.327.625.924.523.121.820.519.318.517.516.715.714.413.111.8-
Ger NL------------------10.8
Ger EFF30.929.327.726.124.623.121.820.619.418.317.216.515.714.914.113.212.411.610.7
Ger Deck00.430.861.21.72.12.533.43.84.34.75.25.96.87.910.814.817.9
Jp PP--------------18.217.216.11514
Jp H40.137.935.833.831.93028.326.725.223.722.321.420.419.318.116.414.713-
Jp NL------------------11.9
Jp EFF3432.230.528.727.125.52422.721.420.11918.217.316.415.514.613.712.811.8
Jp Deck00.390.781.11.51.92.32.73.13.53.94.34.85.46.179.212.515.2
Descent01.42.74.15.46.8911.213.515.717.921.124.327.630.83438.442.847.2
Velocity2300222021402060198019001841178217221663160415811558153615131490150615231539

16英寸/45倍经 Mark 5,Mark 8型火炮,发射Mark 5 Mod 1 - Mod 4型穿甲弹(1939-44年间使用),射弹全重2,240磅,弹体重1,969.2磅;最大射程35,000码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234
Br PP33.631.629.727.82624.222.721.219.918.517.316.515.614.813.913.112.311.4
Br H------------------
Br NL------------------
Br EFF29.928.226.524.823.221.620.218.917.716.515.414.71413.212.411.71110.1
Br Deck00.310.620.931.21.51.82.12.42.73.13.43.84.24.75.26.37.6
US PP38.23633.831.729.627.625.824.222.621.119.718.817.816.915.914.91413
US H------------------
US NL------------------
US EFF34.132.130.228.226.424.62321.620.218.817.516.715.915.114.213.312.511.6
US Deck00.310.620.931.21.51.82.12.42.73.13.43.84.24.75.26.37.6
It PP31.829.928.126.324.622.921.520.118.817.616.415.614.81413.212.411.710.8
It H------------------
It NL------------------
It EFF28.426.725.123.521.920.419.217.916.815.714.613.913.212.511.81110.49.6
It Deck00.380.761.11.51.92.22.633.43.84.24.65.15.76.47.810.2
Ger PP35.133312927.125.323.722.220.819.41817.216.315.514.513.712.911.9
Ger H------------------
Ger NL------------------
Ger EFF31.329.427.625.924.222.521.119.818.517.316.215.314.613.81312.211.510.6
Ger Deck00.370.741.11.41.82.12.52.93.33.74.14.54.95.56.27.69.8
Jp PP40.538.135.833.631.429.227.425.62422.420.819.918.917.916.815.814.913.7
Jp H------------------
Jp NL------------------
Jp EFF34.432.430.428.526.624.823.321.820.41917.716.91615.214.313.412.611.7
Jp Deck00.340.6811.31.722.32.733.43.744.555.66.78.4
Descent01.12.33.54.75.9810.112.114.216.319.422.525.528.631.735.739.8
Velocity252024172315221221102007193118561780170516291598156615351503147214691463

16英寸/45倍经 Mark 5,Mark 8型火炮,发射Mark 5 Mod 5 - Mod 6型穿甲弹(1945-46年间使用),射弹全重2,240磅,弹体重1,911.9磅;最大射程35,000码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234
Br PP---------------13.913.112.1
Br H35.733.631.629.627.625.724.122.621.119.718.417.516.615.814.813.712.511.2
Br NL------------------
Br EFF31.93028.226.424.62321.520.218.817.616.415.614.814.113.212.411.710.8
Br Deck00.310.620.931.21.51.82.12.42.73.13.43.84.24.75.26.37.6
US PP---------------15.914.913.8
US H40.738.33633.731.529.327.525.724.122.520.920191816.915.614.312.8
US NL------------------
US EFF36.334.232.13028.126.224.52321.52018.717.816.91615.114.113.312.3
US Deck00.310.620.931.21.51.82.12.42.73.13.43.84.24.75.26.37.6
It PP---------------13.212.411.5
It H33.831.829.92826.224.422.921.42018.717.416.615.814.9141311.911
It NL------------------
It EFF30.228.426.72523.321.720.419.117.816.715.514.814.113.312.511.811.110.6
It Deck00.380.761.11.51.92.22.633.43.84.24.65.15.76.47.810.2
Ger PP---------------14.513.712.6
Ger H37.335.13330.928.926.925.223.622.120.619.218.317.416.515.514.313.111.7
Ger NL------------------
Ger EFF33.331.329.427.525.72422.52119.718.417.116.315.514.713.81312.211.3
Ger Deck00.370.741.11.41.82.12.52.93.33.74.14.54.95.56.27.69.8
Jp PP---------------16.815.814.6
Jp H43.140.638.135.733.431.129.127.325.523.822.221.120.11917.916.514.813.1
Jp NL------------------
Jp EFF36.634.532.430.328.326.424.723.221.720.218.81817.116.215.214.313.412.4
Jp Deck00.340.6811.31.722.32.733.43.744.555.66.78.4
Descent01.12.33.54.75.9810.112.114.216.319.422.525.528.631.735.739.8
Velocity252024172315221221102007193118561780170516291598156615351503147214691463

14英寸/50倍经 Mark 7,Mark 11型火炮,发射Mark 16 Mod 1 - Mod 6型穿甲弹(1937-44年间使用),射弹全重1,500磅,弹体重1,326磅;最大射程36,800码。

Range024681012141618202224262830323436
Br PP31.529.427.325.223.321.419.918.41715.714.513.712.91211.110.49.89.28.5
Br H-------------------
Br NL------------------7.6
Br EFF28.126.224.322.520.819.117.716.415.21412.912.211.510.79.99.28.78.27.5
Br Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.822.32.62.93.23.64.14.55.46.58.1
US PP34.632.229.927.725.523.421.820.218.717.215.91514.113.212.211.410.810.19.3
US H-------------------
US NL-------------------
US EFF30.828.726.724.722.820.919.41816.715.414.113.312.611.810.910.19.698.3
US Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.822.32.62.93.23.64.14.55.46.58.1
It PP29.927.825.923.92220.218.817.416.114.913.712.912.211.410.59.89.38.78.1
It H-------------------
It NL------------------7.2
It EFF26.624.82321.319.71816.815.514.413.312.211.510.910.19.79.38.37.77.1
It Deck00.310.620.931.21.51.82.12.42.83.13.43.74.24.75.36.48.110.1
Ger PP32.430.22825.923.92220.418.917.516.114.91413.212.411.410.610.19.48.7
Ger H-------------------
Ger NL------------------7.8
Ger EFF28.926.92523.121.319.618.216.915.614.413.212.511.81110.29.598.47.7
Ger Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.74.14.65.26.27.89.8
Jp PP37.735.132.630.227.825.523.82220.418.817.316.315.414.413.312.411.71110.2
Jp H-------------------
Jp NL-------------------
Jp EFF3229.827.725.623.621.720.218.717.315.914.713.913.112.211.310.59.99.38.6
Jp Deck00.280.560.841.11.41.61.92.22.52.83.13.43.84.34.85.878.7
Descent01.12.23.44.55.67.79.91214.216.319.62326.3303336.840.644.4
Velocity2700256824362304217220401950185917691678158815481509146914301390139514001404

14英寸/50倍经 Mark 7,Mark 11型火炮,发射Mark 16 Mod 7 - Mod 11型穿甲弹(1944-46年间使用),射弹全重1,500磅,弹体重1,247.6磅;最大射程36,800码。

Range024681012141618202224262830323436
Br PP---------------1110.49.89.1
Br H33.631.32926.924.822.721.119.618.116.715.414.513.712.811.810.89.99-
Br NL-------------------
Br EFF29.927.925.92422.120.318.917.516.214.913.71312.211.410.69.89.38.78.1
Br Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.822.32.62.93.23.64.14.55.46.58.1
US PP---------------12.111.410.79.9
US H36.834.331.829.427.124.923.221.519.918.316.915.915141311.810.89.9-
US NL-------------------
US EFF32.830.628.426.324.222.220.719.217.716.31514.213.412.511.610.810.29.58.9
US Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.822.32.62.93.23.64.14.55.46.58.1
It PP---------------10.710.29.58.8
It H31.829.627.525.423.421.52018.517.215.814.613.81312.111.210.59.68.8-
It NL-------------------
It EFF28.326.424.522.720.919.217.916.515.314.11312.311.510.8109.29.18.57.9
It Deck00.370.620.931.21.51.82.12.42.83.13.43.74.24.75.36.48.110.1
Ger PP---------------11.310.7109.3
Ger H34.532.128.927.625.423.421.720.118.617.215.814.914.113.112.21110.29.2-
Ger NL-------------------
Ger EFF30.728.626.624.622.720.819.417.916.615.314.113.312.511.710.810.19.68.98.3
Ger Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.74.14.65.26.27.89.8
Jp PP---------------13.212.511.710.8
Jp H40.137.434.732.129.627.225.323.421.72018.417.416.415.314.212.711.510.4-
Jp NL-------------------
Jp EFF34.131.729.527.325.123.121.519.918.41715.614.713.9131211.210.69.99.2
Jp Deck00.280.560.841.11.41.61.92.22.52.83.13.43.84.34.85.878.7
Descent01.12.23.44.55.67.79.91214.216.319.62326.3303336.840.644.4
Velocity2700256824362304217220401950185917691678158815481509146914301390139514001404

14英寸/45倍经 Mark 8,Mark 9,Mark 10,Mark 12型火炮,发射Mark 16 Mod 1 - Mod 6型穿甲弹(1937-44年间使用),射弹全重1,500磅,弹体重1,326磅;最大射程34,800码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234
Br PP30.12825.923.821.819.918.617.115.714.413.212.511.710.910.19.18.57.6
Br H------------------
Br NL------------------
Br EFF26.924.923.121.219.517.816.615.21412.911.811.110.49.798.17.66.7
Br Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.822.32.62.83.13.53.94.85.57.4
US PP3330.628.326.123.921.820.418.717.215.814.513.712.811.911.19.99.48.4
US H------------------
US NL------------------
US EFF29.427.325.323.321.319.518.216.715.414.112.912.211.410.69.98.98.37.4
US Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.822.32.62.83.13.53.94.85.57.4
It PP28.526.524.522.520.718.917.616.214.913.712.511.811.110.69.98.88.37.4
It H------------------
It NL------------------
It EFF25.423.621.820.118.416.815.714.413.312.211.210.59.99.58.87.97.46.6
It Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.644.55.56.69.3
Ger PP30.928.726.624.522.420.519.117.516.214.813.612.81211.210.49.38.87.8
Ger H------------------
Ger NL------------------
Ger EFF27.625.623.721.82018.21715.614.413.212.111.410.7109.38.37.86.9
Ger Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.23.644.45.46.59
Jp PP36.133.430.928.426.123.822.220.418.817.215.814.9141312.110.810.29.1
Jp H------------------
Jp NL------------------
Jp EFF30.628.426.224.222.220.218.917.31614.613.412.611.911.110.39.28.77.7
Jp Deck00.280.560.841.11.41.61.92.22.52.833.33.74.1568
Descent01.32.645.36.78.91113.215.517.62124.127.430.635.839.445.3
Velocity260024682336220420721940186017591669157814881448140913691330129012951300

14英寸/45倍经 Mark 8,Mark 9,Mark 10,Mark 12型火炮,发射Mark 16 Mod 7 - Mod 11型穿甲弹(1944-46年间使用),射弹全重1,500磅,弹体重1,247.6磅;最大射程34,800码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234
Br PP--------------10.89.69.18.1
Br H32.129.727.525.323.221.219.818.216.715.414.113.312.511.610.79.28.4-
Br NL------------------
Br EFF28.626.524.522.620.718.917.616.214.913.712.511.811.110.39.68.68.17.2
Br Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.822.32.62.83.13.53.94.85.57.4
US PP---------------10.6108.9
US H35.132.630.227.825.523.221.719.918.416.815.414.513.712.711.810.19.3-
US NL------------------
US EFF31.329.126.924.822.720.719.317.716.41513.812.912.211.310.59.48.97.9
US Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.822.32.62.83.13.53.94.85.57.4
It PP--------------10.59.48.98.2
It H30.328.226242220.118.717.215.814.513.312.511.81110.498.2-
It NL------------------
It EFF27.125.123.221.419.617.916.715.314.11311.911.210.59.89.48.47.97.4
It Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.644.55.56.69.3
Ger PP--------------11.19.99.38.3
Ger H32.930.628.32623.921.820.318.717.215.814.513.612.811.9119.58.7-
Ger NL------------------
Ger EFF29.427.225.223.221.319.418.116.615.314.112.912.111.410.69.98.88.37.4
Ger Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.23.644.45.46.59
Jp PP--------------12.911.510.99.7
Jp H38.335.532.930.227.825.323.621.72018.316.815.814.913.912.810.89.8-
Jp NL------------------
Jp EFF32.530.227.925.323.621.520.118.41715.614.313.412.611.810.99.89.28.2
Jp Deck00.280.560.841.11.41.61.92.22.52.833.33.74.1568
Descent01.32.645.36.78.91113.215.517.62124.127.430.635.839.445.3
Velocity260024682336220420721940186017591669157814881448140913691330129012951300

14英寸/45倍经 Mark 8,Mark 9,Mark 10,Mark 12型火炮,发射Mark 20 Mod 1型穿甲弹(配用于纽约级),射弹全重1,500磅,弹体重1,315.5磅;最大射程24,000码。

Range024681012141618202224
Br PP30.12825.923.821.819.918.617.115.714.413.212.511.7
Br H-------------
Br NL-------------
Br EFF26.924.923.121.219.517.816.615.21412.911.811.110.4
Br Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.822.32.62.83.1
US PP3330.628.326.123.921.820.418.717.215.814.513.712.8
US H-------------
US NL-------------
US EFF29.427.325.323.321.319.518.216.715.414.112.912.211.4
US Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.822.32.62.83.1
It PP28.526.524.522.520.718.917.616.214.913.712.511.811.1
It H-------------
It NL-------------
It EFF25.423.621.820.118.416.815.714.413.312.211.210.59.9
It Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.6
Ger PP30.928.726.624.522.420.519.117.516.214.813.612.812
Ger H-------------
Ger NL-------------
Ger EFF27.625.623.721.82018.21715.614.413.212.111.410.7
Ger Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.23.6
Jp PP36.133.430.928.426.123.822.220.418.817.215.814.914
Jp H-------------
Jp NL-------------
Jp EFF30.628.426.224.222.220.228.917.31614.613.412.611.9
Jp Deck00.280.560.841.11.41.61.92.22.52.833.3
Descent01.32.645.36.78.91113.215.517.62124.1
Velocity2600246823362204207219401860175916691578148814481409

12英寸/50倍经 Mark 8型火炮,发射Mark 18 Mod 1型穿甲弹(1944-47年间使用),射弹全重1,140磅,弹体重1,002.1磅;最大射程39,573码。

Range02468101214161820222426283032343638
Br PP---------------9.89.28.57.86.9
Br H26.925.223.52220.418.917.616.415.214.11312.311.510.910.39.68.77.7--
Br NL-------------------6.2
Br EFF2422.52119.618.216.815.714.713.612.611.610.910.29.89.38.88.27.676.1
Br Deck00.250.50.7611.21.51.722.22.52.833.43.84.35.47.39.110.3
US PP---------------10.39.78.98.27.3
US H28.326.524.723.121.419.818.517.31614.813.712.912.111.510.910.19.18.1--
US NL--------------------
US EFF25.223.622.120.619.117.716.515.414.313.212.211.510.810.39.79.28.687.36.5
US Deck00.250.50.7611.21.51.722.22.52.833.43.84.35.47.39.110.3
It PP               9.58.98.47.86.9
It H25.523.922.320.819.317.916.615.414.313.212.411.610.810.6109.38.47.6--
It NL--------------------
It EFF22.821.319.918.517.215.914.913.912.911.91110.49.79.48.98.57.97.56.96.1
It Deck00.270.540.8111.31.61.92.12.42.733.33.74.14.76.18.410.512
Ger PP---------------9.99.38.67.97
Ger H27.225.523.822.220.619.117.816.615.414.313.212.411.611.110.59.78.87.9--
Ger NL-------------------6.3
Ger EFF24.322.721.219.818.41715.914.813.712.711.811.110.49.99.48.98.37.67.16.2
Ger Deck00.270.540.8111.31.61.92.12.42.733.33.74.14.668.310.311.7
Jp PP---------------11.610.910.19.38.2
Jp H31.929.927.92624.222.420.919.518.116.715.514.613.61312.311.3108.8--
Jp NL-------------------7
Jp EFF27.125.423.722.120.51917.716.515.314.213.112.311.61110.49.99.38.57.96.9
Jp Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.82.12.32.62.93.23.544.55.77.79.711
Descent012.13.44.7681012.51517.520.623.726.729.732.837.542.246.952
Velocity25002386227221642056194818671786170716281550150414581439142014001411142214371452

请注意:
1)对于美国的新式16寸火炮而言,同样一门火炮,发射Mark 8 Mod 1 - Mod 5型穿甲弹,与Mark 8 Mod 6 - Mod 8型穿甲弹,穿深数据差别相当大。自Mod 6型穿甲弹起,炮弹制造的硬化工艺上有了显著的进步,因而射弹在以35度左右角度入射大厚度表面硬化装甲时,穿深数据有明显提升。此外Mod 6的弹体在大角度命中水平装甲时具有更好的穿透能力。
2)其余老式16寸与14寸火炮,在更换新炮弹后,穿深也有明显提升。
3)从表中我们可以看出,阿拉斯加级配备的新式12寸火炮,垂直穿深仅仅是接近老式14寸/45倍经主炮,并未达到超越的程度,而水平穿深则始终不及。


日本火炮

46厘米/45倍径 94式火炮,发射91式穿甲弹(1937-45年间使用),射弹全重3,219磅,弹体重2,624.3磅;最大射程45,275码。

Range02468101214161820222426283032343638404244
BR PP36.134.132.130.128.226.324.723.221.820.719.818.91817.216.415.314.313.61312.311.711.210.6
BR H-----------------------
BR NL35.333.331.329.427.525.724.222.721.320.319.418.517.716.916.1151413.412.712.111.51110.4
BR EFF31.729.928.226.424.823.221.920.619.318.517.716.916.215.414.713.512.511.811.110.59.89.38.7
BR Deck00.320.640.961.21.61.92.22.52.93.23.53.84.24.55.36.27.28.510.312.313.915.1
USPP42.640.237.735.232.830.628.626.72523.722.521.420.319.318.41715.71514.213.512.812.211.5
US H-----------------------
US NL41.639.236.834.432.129.927.926.124.423.222.12119.9191816.715.514.71413.212.51211.3
US EFF37.435.333.231.229.327.425.824.322.721.620.519.518.517.516.515.113.81312.211.410.710.19.4
US Deck00.320.640.961.21.61.92.22.52.93.23.53.84.24.55.36.27.28.510.312.313.915.1
It PP34.232.330.428.526.724.923.42220.619.618.717.917.116.315.614.513.512.912.311.711.110.610
It H-----------------------
It NL33.431.529.627.826.124.322.921.520.119.218.317.516.71615.314.213.312.712.111.510.910.49.8
It EFF3028.326.72523.52220.719.518.317.516.81615.314.613.912.811.811.210.59.99.38.88.2
It Deck00.410.831.21.622.42.93.33.74.14.555.45.86.88.19.712.315.418.420.622.4
Ger PP38.436.234.131.929.827.82624.422.921.820.719.718.81817.115.914.814.113.412.712.111.510.9
Ger H-----------------------
Ger NL37.435.333.231.129.127.125.523.922.421.320.319.318.417.616.815.614.513.913.212.511.911.310.7
Ger EFF33.731.729.928.126.324.623.221.920.519.718.817.91716.115.314.112.912.211.510.810.19.68.9
Ger Deck00.40.811.21.622.42.83.23.644.44.95.35.66.57.89.311.614.617.419.621.2
JP PP42.139.737.33532.730.528.726.925.22422.921.820.819.918.917.616.415.714.914.113.412.812.1
JP PH-----------------------
JP NL4138.736.434.23229.82826.324.623.522.421.320.419.518.617.316.115.414.613.913.212.611.9
JP EFF36.934.832.830.828.92725.52422.521.520.619.718.717.816.915.614.313.612.81211.310.710
JP Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.53.84.24.64.95.76.77.99.411.613.915.617
Descent01.32.63.95.26.58.19.711.31314.716.518.720.923.127.331.534.737.941444750
Velocity25592462236522672170207319971920184417991754170916751642160815821558156215661570157415801590

41厘米/45倍经 3年式火炮,发射91式穿甲弹(1931-45年间使用),射弹全重2,249磅,弹体重1,894.3磅;最大射程41,995码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234363840
BR PP32.830.127.525.323.72220.719.418.117.216.315.414.714.113.412.611.81110.29.48.3
BR H---------------------
BR NL32.129.426.824.723.221.520.218.917.716.81615.114.413.813.112.311.610.8109.38.1
BR EFF28.826.424.122.220.819.418.217.11615.214.513.713.112.611.91110.29.48.67.87
BR Deck00.280.560.851.11.41.71.92.22.52.83.13.43.744.967.610.112.213.4
US PP37.534.331.328.726.824.823.221.620.219.118.11716.215.414.613.612.711.810.910.19.1
US H---------------------
US NL36.533.530.52826.224.222.621.219.818.717.716.715.915.114.313.412.511.610.79.98.9
US EFF32.930.127.525.323.822.120.819.518.317.316.415.414.613.8131211109.28.37.4
US Deck00.280.560.851.11.41.71.92.22.52.83.13.43.744.967.610.112.213.4
It PP31.128.5262422.520.819.618.317.216.315.514.61413.312.712.311.510.79.99.28.2
It H---------------------
It NL30.327.825.423.421.920.419.117.916.815.915.114.313.713.112.41211.310.59.898
It EFF27.32522.82119.718.317.216.215.214.413.71312.411.911.210.8109.18.47.66.8
It Deck00.340.6811.31.722.42.73.13.43.84.14.54.95.97.410.113.816.618.2
Ger PP34.431.428.726.424.722.921.520.118.817.816.915.915.214.513.812.912.111.210.49.68.7
Ger H---------------------
Ger NL33.530.72825.824.222.42119.618.417.416.515.614.914.213.512.711.81110.29.58.5
Ger EFF30.127.625.223.221.820.21917.916.715.915.214.313.61312.211.310.59.68.887.1
Ger Deck00.330.6711.31.622.32.733.33.744.44.75.87.29.613.215.917.5
JP PP37.834.631.629.127.325.323.722.220.819.718.717.616.816.115.314.313.412.511.610.79.6
JP H---------------------
JP NL36.933.830.828.426.624.723.221.720.319.318.317.316.515.81514.113.212.311.410.69.3
JP EFF33.230.427.725.62422.320.919.718.417.516.715.815.114.413.612.611.610.79.88.97.9
JP Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.644.35.26.48.211.213.414.8
Descent01.42.74.15.16.88.41011.613.615.517.519.822.124.629.33438.743.348.152.8
Velocity264524862327219821002001192318461768172016721616158415521520151815161523153915451552

36厘米/45倍经 41式火炮,发射91式穿甲弹(1931-45年间使用),射弹全重1,485磅,弹体重1,250.6磅;最大射程38,770码(伊势级后部炮塔除外)。

Range02468101214161820222426283032343638
BR PP26.924.822.82119.317.616.615.614.513.612.712.111.410.810.19.58.88.27.67
BR H--------------------
BR NL26.224.222.320.518.817.216.215.214.213.312.411.811.110.59.89.28.687.46.9
BR EFF23.621.82018.416.915.514.613.712.811.911.110.6109.48.88.37.77.16.66.1
BR Deck00.240.490.730.981.21.41.71.92.22.42.72.93.23.54.256.17.68.9
US PP29.527.22522.92119.21816.815.614.613.612.912.111.410.7109.48.78.17.6
US H--------------------
US NL28.826.524.422.420.518.717.616.415.314.213.312.611.911.210.59.89.28.687.5
US EFF25.923.921.920.218.61716151413.112.211.610.910.19.48.88.17.46.86.3
US Deck00.240.490.730.981.21.41.71.92.22.42.72.93.23.54.256.17.68.9
It PP25.523.521.619.918.316.715.814.713.812.81211.410.810.29.598.47.87.26.7
It H--------------------
It NL24.822.921.119.417.816.315.414.413.412.611.711.110.59.99.38.88.27.676.5
It EFF22.320.61917.41614.713.812.912.111.310.5109.58.98.37.87.36.76.25.8
It Deck00.280.560.851.11.41.71.92.22.52.83.13.43.74.14.95.97.49.511.1
Ger PP27.625.523.421.619.818.11715.914.813.812.912.311.610.910.29.698.47.87.2
Ger H--------------------
Ger NL2724.922.92119.317.716.715.614.513.512.61211.410.7109.58.98.27.67
Ger EFF24.222.420.618.917.415.9151413.112.211.410.910.39.798.47.87.26.66.1
Ger Deck00.270.550.821.11.31.61.92.22.42.733.33.644.85.77.29.310.8
JP PP30.628.32623.92220.118.917.716.515.414.413.712.912.211.410.810.19.38.68
JP H--------------------
JP NL29.927.625.323.321.419.618.517.316.115.114.113.412.711.911.210.59.89.18.47.8
JP EFF26.924.822.82119.317.616.615.614.513.612.712.111.410.7109.48.787.46.9
JP Deck00.260.520.7811.31.51.822.32.62.83.13.43.74.55.36.58.39.6
Descent01.42.84.15.56.98.310.312.414.616.81921.824.627.531.735.940.144.348.5
Velocity25432405226721362012188818161744167316041535149614571418137813681358136013681380

请注意:
1)以上火炮所采用的射弹,均为91式穿甲弹。关于1式穿甲弹的问题,NavWeaps上并无详细资料,而在最为权威的USNTMJ报告,O-19号,Japanese Projectiles General Types中,我也没有看到关于1式穿甲弹的描述。因此,对于91式与1式的差异问题,还望各位多多提供具体资料。
2)日本41厘米/45倍经 3年式火炮的弹道数据,初速标为806米/秒,但依据其远距离弹道参数看,更像是780米/秒初速下的弹道数据。
3)日本36厘米/45倍经 41式火炮的实际口径为35.56厘米(14英寸)。


英国火炮

16英寸/45倍经 Mark II,Mark III型火炮,发射16英寸Mark IIb型穿甲弹,射弹全重2,375磅,弹体重2,090磅;最大射程40,000码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234363840
Br PP----------------13.111.810.69.58.4
Br H32.330.62927.425.824.32321.720.419.117.81716.215.414.714.1-----
Br NL-----------------11.210.19.18.1
Br EFF31.930.228.62725.52422.721.420.118.817.616.81615.114.213.412.6----
Br Deck00.330.660.991.31.61.92.32.62.93.33.644.555.66.88.711.313.314.8
US PP--------------16.41513.411.910.69.99.1
US H36.834.93331.229.427.726.224.723.221.720.319.418.417.5-------
US NL-----------------11.410.29.18
US EFF36.334.432.630.829.127.325.924.322.921.520.119.118.217.216.114.612.9----
US Deck00.330.660.991.31.61.92.32.62.93.33.644.555.66.88.711.313.314.8
It PP----------------12.411.11098
It H30.62927.425.924.42321.820.519.318.116.916.115.314.613.913.3-----
It NL-----------------10.69.58.67.6
It EFF30.228.627.125.624.122.721.520.31917.816.715.915.114.313.512.711.9----
It Deck00.40.81.21.622.42.83.23.644.44.95.46.16.98.711.815.418.120.1
Ger PP---------------14.813.311.810.59.48.4
Ger H35.533.631.830.128.326.725.223.822.320.919.618.317.816.91614.4-----
Ger NL-----------------11.210.198
Ger EFF33.331.629.928.226.625.123.722.42119.718.417.516.715.814.91413.6----
Ger Deck00.390.781.11.51.92.32.73.13.53.94.34.85.35.96.78.411.314.817.319.3
Jp PP----------------1513.512.110.810.4
Jp PH37.335.433.531.629.828.126.625.123.52220.619.618.717.817.116.5-----
Jp NL------------------11.310.29.1
Jp EFF36.734.832.931.129.327.626.124.623.121.720.319.318.417.416.415.414.212.6---
Jp Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.53.94.34.85.367.49.612.514.716.4
Descent01.22.43.64.867.79.411.71416.519.722.926.129.132.236.340.444.448.552.6
Velocity240023162233214920661982191518481781171416471617158715581528149815061513154315731603

16英寸/45倍经 Mark I型火炮,发射16英寸Mark Ib型穿甲弹,射弹全重2,048磅,弹体重1,802磅;最大射程39,800码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234363839.8
Br PP-----------------11.810.69.58.5
Br H33.531.429.327.425.423.62220.519.31816.815.91514.313.613.112.4----
Br NL-----------------1110.198.1
Br EFF3331292725.123.321.820.31917.816.615.714.814.113.312.511.6----
Br Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.23.53.94.34.95.66.78.810.912.3
US PP---------------14.813.312.110.79.68.9
US H38.135.733.431.22926.925.123.421.920.519.218.117.116.315.514.7-----
US NL-----------------11.610.29.18.1
US EFF37.635.33330.828.626.524.823.121.720.318.917.916.91615.114.313.9----
US Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.23.53.94.34.95.66.78.810.912.3
It PP-----------------11.210.29.18.1
It H31.729.727.825.924.122.320.919.518.217.115.915.114.213.512.912.411.8----
It NL-----------------10.49.78.77.8
It EFF31.329.327.425.623.822.120.619.21816.815.714.91413.312.611.811----
It Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.53.94.24.75.25.96.98.611.914.816.7
Ger PP----------------13.611.910.69.48.4
Ger H36.734.432.23027.925.924.222.621.119.818.517.516.515.714.914.113----
Ger NL-----------------11.410.198.1
Ger EFF34.532.330.328.226.324.322.721.219.918.617.416.415.514.713.913.112.1----
Ger Deck00.340.6911.31.722.42.73.13.43.84.14.65.15.76.78.311.414.216
Jp PP-----------------13.612.210.810.1
Jp PH38.736.233.931.629.427.325.523.822.320.819.518.417.416.515.815.314.712.8---
Jp NL-------------------10.29.1
Jp EFF3835.633.331.128.926.82523.321.920.519.118.117.116.215.314.413.412.711.4--
Jp Deck00.310.630.951.21.51.92.22.52.83.13.53.74.14.65.267.29.71213.5
Descent01.22.33.54.65.87.49.111.413.615.918.721.624.727.830.934.638.342.747.251.2
Velocity261425002386227221582044195518661796172616561610156515361508147914501464149515271556

15英寸/42倍经 Mark I型火炮,发射15英寸Mark XVIIb型穿甲弹(Cardonald制造),射弹全重1,938磅,弹体重1,705磅;30度仰角时最大射程33,600码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303233.6
Br PP---------------13.41210.9
Br H34.232.230.228.326.424.52321.520.21917.816.915.915.114.313.3--
Br NL-----------------10.4
Br EFF30.528.726.925.223.521.920.519.21816.915.91514.213.512.71211.3-
Br Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.23.64.14.75.46.57.7
US PP--------------15.313.712.111
US H38.73633.731.629.527.425.724.122.621.219.918.917.816.914.4---
US NL-----------------10.5
US EFF34.132.130.128.226.324.522.921.520.218.917.716.815.915.114.212.911.5-
US Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.23.64.14.75.46.57.7
It PP---------------12.711.310.5
It H32.430.528.626.82523.221.820.419.11816.91615.114.313.512.6--
It NL-----------------10
It EFF28.927.225.523.922.320.719.418.217.1161514.213.412.81211.310.9-
It Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.53.94.34.95.56.48.110.1
Ger PP---------------13.411.910.9
Ger H35.533.331.329.327.325.423.822.320.919.718.417.516.515.714.812.9--
Ger NL-----------------10.3
Ger EFF31.629.727.926.124.322.721.219.918.717.516.415.614.71413.212.411.3-
Ger Deck00.340.6911.31.722.42.73.13.43.84.24.85.46.37.89.7
Jp PP---------------15.513.812.5
Jp PH41.138.636.233.931.729.527.625.824.322.821.420.319.118.217.1---
Jp NL-------------- ---
Jp EFF34.932.830.828.826.92523.52220.619.418.217.216.215.414.513.712.711.6
Jp Deck00.320.650.981.31.61.92.22.62.93.23.63.94.455.878.4
Descent01.262.53.756.38.210.112.414.717.220.123.126.529.933.337.240.3
Velocity245823572256215620551955187818011738167516131573153315121491147114751478

15英寸/42倍经 Mark I型火炮,发射15英寸Mark XVIIb型穿甲弹(非Cardonald制造),射弹全重1,938磅,弹体重1,705磅;30度仰角时最大射程33,600码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303233.6
Br PP----------------11.810.9
Br H30.92927.225.523.822.220.819.418.317.116.115.214.413.713.212.7--
Br NL-----------------10.4
Br EFF30.528.726.925.223.521.920.519.21816.915.91514.213.512.71211.3-
Br Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.23.64.14.75.46.57.7
US PP--------------14.613.311.910.9
US H34.532.530.428.526.624.823.221.720.419.2181716.115.4----
US NL-----------------10.5
US EFF34.132.130.128.226.324.522.921.520.218.917.716.815.915.114.212.911.5-
US Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.23.64.14.75.46.57.7
It PP----------------11.410.5
It H29.327.525.824.222.52119.718.417.316.215.214.413.61312.512--
It NL-----------------10
It EFF28.927.225.523.922.320.719.418.217.1161514.213.412.81211.310.9-
It Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.53.94.34.95.56.48.110.1
Ger PP---------------13.211.910.9
Ger H33.631.629.727.825.924.122.621.219.918.717.516.615.714.914.212.9--
Ger NL-----------------10.3
Ger EFF31.629.727.926.124.322.721.219.918.717.516.415.614.71413.212.411.3-
Ger Deck00.340.6911.31.722.42.73.13.43.84.24.85.46.37.89.7
Jp PP---------------14.813.512.4
Jp PH35.533.431.329.327.425.523.922.32119.718.517.516.515.915.314.7--
Jp NL------------------
Jp EFF34.932.830.828.826.92523.52220.619.418.217.216.215.414.513.712.711.6
Jp Deck00.320.650.981.31.61.92.22.62.93.23.63.94.455.878.4
Descent01.262.53.756.38.210.112.414.717.220.123.126.529.933.337.240.3
Velocity245823572256215620551955187818011738167516131573153315121491147114751478

15英寸/42倍经 Mark I型火炮,发射15英寸Mark XIIIa型穿甲弹,射弹全重1,920磅,弹体重1,690磅;30度仰角时最大射程29,000码,20度仰角时最大射程23,734码。

Range024681012141618202224262829
Br PP--------------10.710
Br H3128.826.624.522.420.418.917.616.114.813.512.712.111.7--
Br NL--------------109.5
Br EFF30.628.426.324.222.120.218.717.315.914.613.312.511.610.8--
Br Deck00.330.660.991.31.61.92.32.62.93.33.84.55.56.87.8
US PP-------------12.210.810.1
US H34.632.229.827.425.122.821.219.61816.51514.213.5---
US NL--------------10.39.6
US EFF34.231.829.427.124.822.520.919.417.816.314.913.91311.7--
US Deck00.330.660.991.31.61.92.32.62.93.33.84.55.56.87.8
It PP--------------10.19.5
It H29.327.225.223.221.219.317.916.615.31412.71211.511--
It NL--------------9.59
It EFF2926.924.922.92119.117.716.415.113.812.611.81110.3--
It Deck00.390.781.11.51.92.32.73.13.53.94.65.46.68.710.2
Ger PP-------------12.110.710
Ger H33.831.32926.724.422.220.619.117.616.114.713.81311.8--
Ger NL--------------10.29.5
Ger EFF31.729.427.325.122.920.919.417.916.515.113.812.91211.2--
Ger Deck00.380.761.11.51.92.22.633.43.84.55.26.48.49.8
Jp PP-------------13.712.211.5
Jp PH35.633.130.628.225.823.521.820.218.51715.514.714.113.6--
Jp NL----------------
Jp EFF3532.530.127.725.323.121.419.818.216.715.214.313.312.411.410.7
Jp Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.54.14.85.97.48.5
Descent01.22.445.67.39.812.315.618.922.326.530.735.239.742
Velocity2467234222172093196818431763168316041524144414201396138813931398

15英寸/42倍经 Mark I型火炮,发射15英寸Mark Va型穿甲弹(Blue Band),射弹全重1,917磅,弹体重1,687磅;30度仰角时最大射程29,000码。

Range024681012141618202224262829
Br PP---------15.914.513.612.711.810.910.5
Br H33.33128.726.424.12220.418.917.315.413.712.4----
Br NL-------------10.59.89.4
Br EFF29.727.625.623.521.519.618.216.815.514.212.912.111.310.298.5
Br Deck00.330.660.991.31.61.92.32.62.93.33.84.55.56.87.8
US PP--------19.417.816.215.214.213.212.211.8
US H37.334.63229.52724.622.821.119.317.215.313.9----
US NL-------------11.810.910.5
US EFF33.230.928.626.324.121.920.318.817.315.814.413.512.611.410.19.5
US Deck00.330.660.991.31.61.92.32.62.93.33.84.55.56.87.8
It PP--------16.41513.712.91211.210.49.9
It H31.629.327.12522.820.819.317.916.314.612.911.8----
It NL-------------109.28.9
It EFF28.126.124.222.320.418.517.215.914.613.412.211.510.79.68.68
It Deck00.390.781.11.51.92.32.73.13.53.94.65.46.68.710.2
Ger PP--------1816.51514.113.112.211.310.9
Ger H34.532.129.727.32522.821.119.617.915.914.212.9----
Ger NL-------------10.910.19.7
Ger EFF30.828.626.524.322.320.318.817.41614.713.412.511.710.59.48.8
Ger Deck00.380.761.11.51.92.22.633.43.84.55.26.48.49.8
Jp PP----------17.416.315.214.213.112.6
Jp PH4037.234.431.62926.424.522.720.819.116.915.213.5---
Jp NL-------------1211.210.7
Jp EFF3431.629.226.924.622.420.819.317.716.214.813.912.911.710.49.7
Jp Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.54.14.85.97.48.5
Descent01.22.445.67.39.812.315.618.922.326.530.735.239.742
Velocity2467234222172093196818431763168316041524144414201396138813931398

15英寸/42倍经 Mark I型火炮,发射15英寸Mark IIIa型穿甲弹(Green Boy),射弹全重1,910磅,弹体重1,680磅;20度仰角时最大射程24,000码。

Range024681012141618202224
Br PP33.33128.726.424.121.920.118.216.314.412.711.310
Br H-------------
Br NL-27.625.623.521.519.61816.414.713.111.610.49.3
Br EFF29.726.523.520.518.116.114.312.911.610.59.68.98.3
Br Deck00.330.660.991.31.61.92.32.62.93.33.84.5
US PP37.334.63229.526.924.322.12017.715.613.61210.6
US H-------------
US NL-30.928.626.324.121.819.918.116.114.212.511.19.8
US EFF33.229.225.622.119.31714.913.411.910.79.78.98.3
US Deck00.330.660.991.31.61.92.32.62.93.33.84.5
It PP31.629.327.12522.820.81917.315.413.712119.7
It H-------------
It NL-26.124.222.320.418.51715.513.912.41110.19
It EFF28.125.122.219.417.215.213.612.2119.99.18.58
It Deck00.390.781.11.51.92.32.73.13.53.94.65.4
Ger PP34.532.129.727.32522.620.718.816.714.81311.510.2
Ger H-------------
Ger NL-28.626.524.322.320.318.616.915.113.411.910.69.4
Ger EFF30.827.324.12118.416.314.51311.610.59.68.98.2
Ger Deck00.380.761.11.51.92.22.633.43.84.55.2
Jp PP4037.234.431.72926.223.921.719.317.11513.311.7
Jp PH-------------
Jp NL-31.629.226.924.622.420.618.716.814.913.211.810.5
Jp EFF3430.226.723.320.618.216.214.61311.810.8109.3
Jp Deck00.350.711.41.72.12.42.83.13.54.14.8
Descent01.22.445.67.39.812.315.618.922.326.530.7
Velocity2467234222172093196818431763168316041524144414201396

14英寸/45倍经 Mark VII型火炮,发射14英寸Mark VIIb型穿甲弹,射弹全重1,590磅,弹体重1,399磅;最大射程38,600。

Range02468101214161820222426283032343638.6
Br PP----------------11.610.69.37.8
Br H29.127.425.824.222.621.219.918.617.516.515.514.713.913.312.812.311.5---
Br NL-----------------10.18.97.5
Br EFF28.727.125.423.922.420.919.618.417.316.315.314.513.813.112.411.710.9---
Br Deck00.270.550.821.11.31.61.92.22.42.733.33.74.24.75.56.99.412
US PP---------------13.111.710.69.27.9
US H31.93028.226.524.823.221.820.419.218.11716.115.314.614-----
US NL-----------------10.18.87.4
US EFF31.529.727.926.224.522.921.520.21917.916.815.915.114.413.612.711.3---
US Deck00.270.550.821.11.31.61.92.22.42.733.33.74.24.75.56.99.412
It PP----------------1110.28.97.6
It H27.525.924.422.921.42018.817.616.615.614.713.913.212.612.111.610.9---
It NL-----------------9.78.57.3
It EFF27.225.624.122.621.219.818.617.416.415.414.513.81312.411.811.110.3---
It Deck00.320.650.971.31.61.92.22.62.93.23.53.94.34.85.46.58.411.815
Ger PP----------------11.710.69.27.7
Ger H31.429.627.826.124.422.821.520.118.917.816.815.915.114.413.713.1----
Ger NL-----------------108.87.4
Ger EFF29.527.826.124.52321.520.218.917.816.715.714.914.213.512.812.111.2---
Ger Deck00.310.630.941.21.51.82.22.52.83.13.43.84.24.75.36.38.211.514.6
Jp PP----------------13.212.110.69.1
Jp PH33.331.329.527.725.924.222.721.320.118.917.716.81615.314.714.212.7---
Jp NL-------------------8.4
Jp EFF32.730.82927.225.423.822.32119.718.517.416.515.714.914.113.412.411.310-
Jp Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.23.53.94.455.97.410.213
Descent01.22.43.64.867.79.411.714.116.519.32225.128.231.335.13943.850.2
Velocity24832385228721892091199419171840177817171657161615751550152615021478150015311571

请注意:
1)除16英寸Mark II与Mark III外,其余英国火炮的初速数据,都是按新炮初速计算的。其中16英寸Mark I,是按照使用Mark II膛线的初速数据计算的。16英寸Mark II与Mark III的初速数据,是按旧炮初速计算的。
2)15英寸Mark XVIIb型穿甲弹,分卡尔多诺德(Cardonald)制造与非卡尔多诺德(Non-Cardonald)制造两种数据,根据Nathan Okun的说法,卡尔多诺德(Cardonald)制造的穿甲弹,弹尖硬度更大,中段强度更高,因此穿深更高。但这两种射弹对垂直装甲的有效穿深极限数据,与水平穿深数据是完全相同的。
3)上述两种炮弹的数据表现不同处在于:部分穿透数据与穿孔极限数据。部分穿透数据,指射弹一部分破损,但仍有一部分成功穿入装甲的情况。这种情况下,射弹有可能已经无法有效爆炸了。穿孔极限数据,则指的是炮弹未能穿透装甲,但在装甲上冲出一块碎块,将其成功挤向装甲的后方。可见,这两种情况,考验的都是弹体的结构强度,因此卡尔多诺德(Cardonald)炮弹占优。
4)15英寸Mark XVIIb型穿甲弹,标注为采用了强装药,但根据其在0距离时的着速2458英尺/秒来看,应该是标准装药的数据,疑似该表写错。
5)根据NavWeaps的说法,胡德,皇家橡树,以及反击这三艘战舰从未配备过15英寸Mark XVIIb型穿甲弹。因此,胡德在对阵俾斯麦时,配备的很有可能是15英寸Mark XIIIa型穿甲弹,这条数据很有参考价值。
6)15英寸Mark XVIIb型穿甲弹的弹型,名义上是6crh,实际为5/10crh。15英寸Mark XIIIa型穿甲弹,15英寸Mark Va型穿甲弹,以及15英寸Mark IIIa型穿甲弹的弹型,名义上是4crh,实际为3.05/4crh。通过比较上述二表可以看到,Mark XIIIa型的初速还略高于Mark XVIIb型,但随着距离增加,存速降低较快。这是由于气动外形较差的弹型造成的。此外,Mark XIIIa型在近距离的穿深并不落后于Mark XVIIb型,而随着距离增加,逐渐开始拉开差距。这是与其存速较低相关联的。
7)15英寸Mark Va型穿甲弹(Blue Band)于1923年入役,替代了15英寸Mark IIIa型穿甲弹(Green Boy)。
8)14英寸/45倍经 Mark VII型火炮配的炮弹,原文写作14英寸Mark Ib型穿甲弹,而根据NavWeaps的说法,应为14英寸Mark VIIb型穿甲弹,疑似该表写错。


德国火炮

40.6厘米/52倍经 SK C/34型火炮,发射穿甲弹,射弹全重2,271磅,弹体重1,998磅;最大射程40,245码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234363840
Br PP32.430.829.127.525.924.422.921.420.21917.916.815.81514.213.312.812.111.510.810.1
Br H---------------------
Br NL31.63028.426.825.323.822.320.919.718.517.416.415.414.613.81312.511.911.310.69.8
Br EFF3028.52725.42422.621.219.818.717.616.515.514.613.81312.111.510.810.29.58.8
Br Deck00.260.520.7911.31.51.82.12.32.62.93.13.43.744.55.167.18.7
US PP36.935.133.231.329.527.826.124.42321.720.419.21817.116.115.114.313.512.811.911.1
US H---------------------
US NL3634.232.430.628.827.125.423.822.421.119.918.717.616.615.714.71413.212.511.710.8
US EFF34.232.430.72927.325.724.122.521.32018.817.716.515.514.513.512.71211.210.49.5
US Deck00.260.520.7911.31.51.82.12.32.62.93.13.43.744.55.167.18.7
It PP30.729.127.62624.623.121.720.219.11816.915.91514.213.412.612.111.510.910.69.8
It H---------------------
It NL3028.426.925.42422.521.119.718.617.616.515.514.613.813.112.311.811.210.710.39.6
It EFF28.42725.524.122.721.42018.717.716.715.614.713.813.112.311.510.910.29.69.38.6
It Deck00.320.650.981.31.61.92.22.62.93.23.63.94.24.64.85.46.27.49.211.9
Ger PP33.932.130.428.727.125.523.922.321.119.918.717.616.515.614.813.913.312.611.911.210.4
Ger H---------------------
Ger NL3331.329.72826.424.923.321.820.619.418.217.116.115.314.413.61312.311.610.910.2
Ger EFF31.329.728.226.62523.622.120.719.518.417.316.215.314.413.512.611.911.210.59.89
Ger Deck00.310.620.941.21.51.82.12.52.83.13.43.744.44.75.367.28.911.4
Jp PP37.335.433.531.629.828.126.324.623.221.920.519.318.217.216.315.314.713.913.212.411.5
Jp PH---------------------
Jp NL36.434.532.730.929.127.425.72422.621.32018.917.716.815.91514.313.612.912.111.3
Jp EFF34.532.73129.327.62624.322.721.520.21917.916.815.914.913.913.112.411.610.810
Jp Deck00.280.570.851.11.41.71.92.22.52.83.13.43.744.34.85.46.47.79.6
Descent00.881.82.93.956.27.49.2111315.217.419.822.224.527.530.53437.541
Velocity265725612465236922732179208319871918184917801717165416081562151415031493150015071514

38厘米/52倍经 SK C/34型火炮,发射穿甲弹,射弹全重1,764磅,弹体重1,552磅;最大射程39,590码。

Range02468101214161820222426283032343638
Br PP32.230.428.626.825.123.52220.619.21816.915.814.914.113.312.611.911.310.69.9
Br H--------------------
Br NL31.429.627.926.124.522.921.520.118.717.616.415.414.513.712.912.311.61110.49.7
Br EFF31.129.327.525.824.222.621.219.918.517.416.315.214.313.412.511.710.910.39.69
Br Deck00.250.50.7511.21.51.722.22.52.733.33.64.14.85.56.37.5
US PP363431.929.928.126.224.62321.520.118.817.616.715.714.713.81312.311.510.8
US H--------------------
US NL35.133.131.129.227.425.62422.520.919.618.417.216.315.414.413.512.71211.310.6
US EFF34.832.830.828.927.125.323.722.320.719.418.116.915.814.713.712.811.911.110.49.6
US Deck00.250.50.7511.21.51.722.22.52.733.33.64.14.85.56.37.5
It PP30.528.82725.423.822.220.819.518.2171614.914.113.312.611.911.210.7109.4
It H--------------------
It NL29.828.126.424.723.221.720.31917.716.615.614.513.81312.311.71110.49.89.2
It EFF29.427.726.124.522.921.420.118.817.516.415.414.413.512.711.811.110.49.89.18.5
It Deck00.30.610.921.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.744.24.95.66.67.89.7
Ger PP33.431.529.627.72624.322.821.319.918.717.516.315.414.613.71312.211.610.910.2
Ger H--------------------
Ger NL32.630.728.827.125.423.722.220.819.418.21715.915.114.213.412.711.911.310.710
Ger EFF32.230.428.526.825.123.52220.619.21816.815.714.713.812.91211.210.59.89.1
Ger Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.63.94.14.85.56.47.69.4
Jp PP36.834.732.730.628.726.925.223.62220.619.31817.116.115.214.413.512.812.111.3
Jp PH--------------------
Jp NL3633.931.929.92826.224.62321.420.118.817.616.615.714.814.113.212.611.811.1
Jp EFF35.633.531.529.527.725.924.322.721.219.918.617.416.315.314.313.412.511.710.910.2
Jp Deck00.270.550.821.11.31.61.92.22.42.733.33.63.84.45.15.86.88.2
Descent00.881.83.24.55.87.38.810.412.414.416.51921.52427.53134.137.240.3
Velocity26902579246723642262216020701980188918161743167016221575152815181509151115131516

28厘米/54.5倍经 SK C/34型火炮,发射穿甲弹,射弹全重727磅,弹体重640磅;最大射程46,749码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234363840424446
Br PP25.723.922.120.418.817.215.814.513.512.511.410.59.89.18.587.476.66.265.75.34.8
Br H------------------------
Br NL25.123.321.619.918.316.815.414.113.212.211.210.29.68.98.27.87.36.96.565.85.55.24.7
Br EFF23.72220.418.917.315.914.613.312.511.510.59.798.37.67.16.66.25.85.45.14.94.64.1
Br Deck00.190.380.570.760.951.11.31.51.71.92.12.32.52.73.13.64.24.95.977.88.69.3
US PP26.424.622.82119.317.716.314.913.912.811.810.810.19.48.78.17.67.16.76.265.75.44.89
US H------------------------
US NL25.82422.220.518.917.315.914.513.612.511.510.59.89.28.57.97.476.56.15.95.65.34.8
US EFF24.422.72119.417.816.31513.712.911.810.99.99.28.57.87.26.76.35.85.45.24.94.64.1
US Deck00.190.380.570.760.951.11.31.51.71.92.12.32.52.73.13.64.24.95.977.88.69.3
It PP24.322.62119.417.816.31513.712.811.810.810.19.48.88.17.87.36.96.56.46.15.85.54.9
It H------------------------
It NL23.722.120.418.917.415.914.613.412.511.510.69.89.28.67.97.67.16.76.36.265.75.44.8
It EFF22.420.919.317.916.41513.812.611.810.9109.38.787.376.465.65.55.354.74.2
It Deck00.20.40.60.811.21.41.61.822.22.42.72.93.43.94.55.46.67.88.89.610.4
Ger PP25.82422.220.518.917.315.914.513.612.511.510.59.89.28.587.476.66.15.95.65.34.8
Ger H------------------------
Ger NL25.223.421.72018.416.815.514.213.312.211.210.29.68.98.37.87.36.96.465.85.55.24.7
Ger EFF23.822.120.518.917.415.914.613.412.511.510.69.798.37.67.16.66.25.85.35.14.84.54.1
Ger Deck00.20.40.60.811.21.41.61.822.22.42.62.93.33.84.55.46.57.78.69.510.2
Jp PP28.926.924.92321.119.317.816.315.21412.911.81110.39.58.98.47.97.46.96.76.46.56.6
Jp PH------------------------
Jp NL28.226.224.322.420.618.917.315.914.913.712.511.510.7109.38.78.27.77.26.86.56.25.95.3
Jp EFF26.724.82321.219.517.816.4151412.911.910.910.19.48.687.46.96.565.85.45.14.6
Jp Deck00.20.40.60.811.21.41.61.822.22.42.62.83.33.84.45.26.37.48.39.19.8
Descent00.921.92.83.74.66.48.29.912.414.917.420.523.626.730.233.73740.343.646.549.452.355.2
Velocity292027692618246823182168204819281848175516621569151714651413139513781386139414021439147615131551

28厘米/52倍经 SK C/28型火炮,发射穿甲弹,射弹全重661磅,弹体重583磅;最大射程39,890码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234363839.8
Br PP2119.217.515.914.412.911.610.49.28.37.36.45.754.44.23.93.83.73.63.5
Br H---------------------
Br NL20.518.717.115.51412.611.410.298.17.16.35.64.94.34.13.83.332.62.1
Br EFF19.517.816.214.713.31210.79.68.47.56.65.85.14.53.93.53.12.92.72.31.9
Br Deck00.170.340.510.680.8611.21.31.51.71.92.32.73.13.74.355.566.5
US PP21.619.81816.414.813.31210.79.58.57.56.55.85.14.443.93.83.83.73.6
US H---------------------
US NL21.119.317.61614.51311.710.59.38.37.36.45.754.33.93.83.332.62.1
US EFF2018.316.715.213.712.3119.88.77.76.75.95.24.63.93.53.12.92.72.41.9
US Deck00.170.340.510.680.8611.21.31.51.71.92.32.73.13.74.355.566.5
It PP19.918.216.615.113.612.211108.97.97.26.35.95.24.54.143.93.93.83.6
It H---------------------
It NL19.417.816.214.713.311.910.89.88.77.776.15.85.14.443.93.33.12.72.2
It EFF18.416.915.31412.611.310.29.28.17.26.55.75.34.643.63.232.82.42
It Deck00.190.380.570.760.951.11.31.51.71.92.12.42.93.444.85.56.26.77.2
Ger PP21.119.317.61614.51311.710.49.38.37.36.45.754.44.13.93.83.73.63.5
Ger H---------------------
Ger NL20.618.817.115.614.112.711.410.298.17.16.35.64.94.343.83.232.62.1
Ger EFF19.517.916.314.813.41210.89.68.57.56.65.85.14.53.93.53.12.92.72.31.9
Ger Deck00.190.380.570.760.951.11.31.51.71.92.12.42.83.344.75.46.16.67.1
Jp PP23.621.619.717.916.214.513.111.710.49.38.27.26.465.65.45.215.45.65.85.9
Jp PH---------------------
Jp NL2321.119.217.515.814.212.811.410.19.1876.35.95.55.35.23.73.42.92.4
Jp EFF21.92018.216.61513.512.110.89.58.47.46.55.74.94.43.93.53.332.62.2
Jp Deck00.180.360.540.720.911.21.41.61.822.42.83.33.94.65.35.86.46.8
Descent00.881.834.25.47.49.411.414.818.221.626.33135.740.144.548.251.955.659.3
Velocity298627942602242922562083193717911645153814311324127012161162116011591187121512431271

请注意:德国两款28厘米火炮的实际口径为28.3厘米。

法国火炮

380毫米/45倍经 M1935型火炮,发射原配法制穿甲弹,射弹全重1,949磅,弹体重1,715磅;最大射程45,600码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234363840424445.6
Br PP33.731.829.927.625.623.822.220.819.217.716.615.514.513.712.812.211.61110.510.19.79.38.98.2
Br H------------------------
Br NL-------------------9.99.59.28.88
Br EFF32.93129.126.92523.221.720.318.817.316.315.214.213.412.611.911.410.810.39.89.28.88.37.4
Br Deck00.280.560.841.11.41.61.92.22.52.83.13.33.644.555.96.98.310.211.913.515.2
US PP37.735.533.430.728.426.324.522.82119.318.116.815.614.713.71312.311.711.110.610.29.89.38.6
US H------------------------
US NL------------------10.910.5109.69.28.4
US EFF36.834.632.63027.725.723.922.320.618.917.716.515.314.413.512.712.111.510.810.39.79.38.88
US Deck00.280.560.841.11.41.61.92.22.52.83.13.33.644.555.96.98.310.211.913.515.2
It PP31.930.128.326.224.222.52119.618.216.815.714.713.712.912.211.51110.49.99.69.18.88.47.7
It H------------------------
It NL-----------------10.39.89.498.78.37.5
It EFF31.129.327.625.523.72220.519.217.816.415.414.413.512.711.911.310.710.29.79.28.88.47.97
It Deck00.320.650.971.31.61.92.22.62.93.23.53.94.24.75.367.18.710.813.315.517.519.6
Ger PP34.932.930.928.626.424.522.921.419.818.21715.914.81413.112.411.811.210.710.29.89.498.3
Ger H------------------------
Ger NL------------------10.510.19.69.38.98.1
Ger EFF34.132.130.227.925.823.922.320.919.317.816.715.614.513.712.812.211.61110.49.99.498.57.6
Ger Deck00.310.630.941.21.51.82.22.52.83.13.43.84.24.65.25.86.98.410.412.81516.918.9
Jp PP38.636.334.231.629.227.125.323.721.920.218.917.716.515.514.613.813.212.511.911.410.910.610.19.2
Jp H                        
Jp NL                  11.711.210.810.49.99.1
Jp EFF37.636.433.330.828.626.524.723.121.419.718.517.316.215.214.313.512.912.311.611.110.5109.58.4
Jp Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.63.84.34.85.46.37.4911.11314.816.5
Descent00.791.62.845.46.78.210.112.414.416.919.722.525.728.731.63538.24144.247.55154.8
Velocity272326072493235722372130203519521861177117081646158915461512149014791475148214961520155516041668

380毫米/45倍经 M1935型火炮,发射原配法制穿甲弹,但使用敦刻尔克级的发射药包,射弹全重1,949磅,弹体重1,715磅;最大射程43,000码。

Range02468101214161820222426283032343638404243
Br PP33.330.428.226.324.522.921.219.618.31715.914.914.113.212.511.811.210.710.29.79.38.88
Br H-----------------------
Br NL------------------109.59.18.67.8
Br EFF32.529.727.625.723.922.420.719.217.916.615.514.613.812.912.211.61110.59.99.38.88.17.2
Br Deck00.290.580.871.161.451.7422.322.62.93.23.43.74.24.75.56.47.89.711.613.414.7
US PP37.23431.629.327.225.423.321.62018.517.216.215.214.213.312.611.911.310.710.29.89.28.5
US H-----------------------
US NL------------------10.5109.698.4
US EFF36.333.230.828.626.624.822.821.119.618.116.915.814.913.913.112.411.711.110.49.89.38.77.9
US Deck00.290.580.871.161.451.7422.322.62.93.23.43.74.24.75.56.47.89.711.613.414.7
It PP31.528.826.724.923.221.72018.617.316.11514.113.312.511.811.210.610.39.99.498.57.8
It H-----------------------
It NL-----------------10.29.79.28.98.47.7
It EFF30.728.126.124.322.721.219.618.216.915.714.713.91312.211.61110.410.19.698.587.1
It Deck00.330.660.991.31.61.92.32.62.93.33.644.44.95.56.67.910.112.715.117.419
Ger PP34.531.529.327.225.323.721.820.218.817.416.315.314.413.512.712.111.410.810.39.89.48.98.2
Ger H-----------------------
Ger NL-----------------10.710.19.79.38.78.1
Ger EFF33.630.828.526.624.723.121.319.818.417.115.91514.113.212.511.811.210.6109.48.98.37.5
Ger Deck00.320.650.971.31.61.92.22.62.93.23.53.94.34.85.46.47.79.712.214.616.818.4
Jp PP3834.832.330.12826.224.122.420.919.318.117161514.213.412.712.111.51110.59.99.2
Jp H-----------------------
Jp NL------------------11.310.810.49.89
Jp EFF37.13431.529.327.425.623.621.920.418.917.716.715.714.713.913.212.511.911.210.5109.38.3
Jp Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.644.455.96.98.510.612.714.716.1
Descent00.81.934.35.67.39.11113.315.718.120.824273033.736.940.243.647.251.454.7
Velocity26902515238322652160206619621873179617191656160415571518149114741466146914811503153715901638

380毫米/45倍经 M1935型火炮,发射美制穿甲弹,使用美国发射药包,射弹全重1,949磅,弹体重1,715磅;最大射程41,065码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234363841
Br PP----------------13.912.912.612.111.6
Br H34.53331.429.928.527.125.523.922.42119.618.317.116.315.514.813.812.511.911.210.4
Br NL---------------------
Br EFF30.829.42826.725.424.122.721.32018.717.516.315.214.513.813.212.411.511.210.810.3
Br Deck00.270.550.821.11.31.61.92.22.42.733.33.63.94.34.95.56.68.410.7
US PP-----------------14.41413.613
US H38.636.935.133.531.830.338.526.725.123.521.920.519.118.217.316.615.51413.312.511.7
US NL---------------------
US EFF34.432.931.329.928.42725.423.922.420.919.618.31716.215.414.813.812.912.512.111.6
US Deck00.270.550.821.11.31.61.92.22.42.733.33.63.94.34.95.56.68.410.7
It PP-----------------12.211.911.511
It H32.731.229.828.42725.624.122.621.219.918.617.316.215.414.61413.111.911.310.69.9
It NL---------------------
It EFF29.127.826.525.324.122.921.520.218.917.716.615.514.413.713.112.511.710.910.610.29.8
It Deck00.330.660.991.31.61.92.32.62.93.33.63.94.34.65.15.86.68.310.913.9
Ger PP----------------14.413.41312.612
Ger H35.734.132.63129.52826.424.823.221.720.31917.716.91615.314.31312.311.610.8
Ger NL---------------------
Ger EFF31.930.429.127.726.32523.522.120.719.418.116.915.81514.313.712.811.911.611.210.7
Ger Deck00.310.630.941.21.51.82.22.52.83.13.43.84.24.555.76.5810.613.5
Jp PP-----------------15.515.114.613.9
Jp H41.439.637.73634.232.530.628.726.925.223.62220.519.618.617.816.614.913.91312
Jp NL---------------------
Jp EFF35.233.632.130.529.127.62624.422.921.42018.717.416.615.815.114.113.212.812.411.8
Jp Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.63.94.24.65.25.97.19.211.7
Descent0123457911.113.115.217.219.321.824.32730.333.636.940.343.8
Velocity257524972419234122632185210720291951187317951717164416081572155515201485151615521585

330毫米/50倍经 M1931型火炮,发射穿甲弹,射弹全重1,235磅,弹体重1,087磅;最大射程45,600码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234363840424445,6
Br PP30.528.827.225.624.122.621.219.918.617.316.114.914.112.811.410.29.28.37.53776.76.35.9
Br H------------------------
Br NL------------------7.56.86.86.66.14.9
Br EFF29.728.126.52523.52220.719.418.216.915.714.513.712.711.310.19.18.27.476.76.66.15.44.8
Br Deck00.220.440.660.891.11.31.51.722.22.42.62.93.13.43.84.24.85.55.86.99.210.4
US PP32.730.929.227.525.924.322.821.42018.617.31614.312.5119.88.88.17.97.57.57.26.76.4
US H------------------------
US NL------------------7.77.37.37.16.64.68
US EFF31.930.228.526.825.223.722.220.919.518.216.915.614.212.410.99.78.787.676.96.55.84.6
US Deck00.220.440.660.891.11.31.51.722.22.42.62.93.13.43.84.24.85.55.86.99.210.4
It PP28.927.325.824.322.821.420.118.917.616.415.214.113.312.110.89.78.727.97.1876.96.76.35.9
It H------------------------
It NL------------------7.136.86.86.66.14.7
It EFF28.126.625.123.722.320.919.618.417.21614.913.7131210.79.68.717.87.16.56.46.15.44.6
It Deck00.250.50.7511.21.51.722.22.52.733.33.53.94.24.85.56.36.78.31112.5
Ger PP31.129.427.726.124.62321.620.31917.716.415.214.312.611.21098.17.57.17.16.96.46
Ger H------------------------
Ger NL------------------7.376.96.76.24.8
Ger EFF30.328.62725.52422.521.119.818.517.21614.81412.511.19.98.987.26.76.66.25.54.7
Ger Deck00.240.490.730.981.21.41.71.92.22.42.72.93.23.53.84.24.75.46.26.68.110.812.2
Jp PP34.532.730.82927.325.624.122.621.119.618.216.91614.312.711.3110.29.28.68.58.58.47.97.7
Jp H------------------------
Jp NL-------------------8.48.38.17.75.5
Jp EFF33.731.930.128.326.62523.52220.619.217.816.415.614.212.611.310.179.18.587.97.77.45.4
Jp Deck00.230.470.710.951.11.41.61.92.12.32.62.83.13.33.644.55.15.86.27.49.811.2
Descent00.951.92.93.84.86.17.48.710.512.314.216.919.622.32527.730.633.536.437.340.144.748.3
Velocity285427452636252724182309221421192024193118381745169616471598156915401531152215131521153715571573

请注意:
1)法国380mm M1935的穿深数据,法制炮弹与美制炮弹的表现差异较大。尽管美制炮弹的初速较低,在近距离时穿深较低,但在远距离上的存速表现较好,穿深也较高,这有可能是计算时输入的数据有误导致的。根据我所了解的资料,法国原装炮弹与美制炮弹的弹型是基本相同的,气动性能理应相似,存速性能不应有这么大的差别。
2)法国380mm M1935的初速数据有误。按照我手头的参考资料,使用敦刻尔克级的发射药时,其初速为785米/秒,而使用美国发射药时,则为800米/秒。


意大利火炮

381毫米/50倍经 M1934型火炮,发射穿甲弹,射弹全重1,951磅,弹体重1,717磅;最大射程46,219码。

Range0246810121416182022242628303234363840424446
Br PP35.73432.230.528.827.225.724.322.921.620.419.218.317.516.615.915.214.313.412.411.610.89.88.2
Br H------------------------
Br NL---------------------9.68.77.3
Br EFF31.930.328.727.225.724.222.921.620.419.318.217.216.415.614.814.213.612.81211.110.39.58.67
Br Deck00.250.510.7711.21.51.722.32.52.833.33.63.94.355.97.19.31213.815.2
US PP40383634.132.230.428.727.125.624.222.821.520.519.518.617.817161513.91312.1119.1
US H------------------------
US NL---------------------10.79.88.1
US EFF35.633.932.130.428.727.125.624.222.821.620.319.218.317.416.615.915.214.313.412.411.610.69.67.9
US Deck00.250.510.7711.21.51.722.32.52.833.33.63.94.355.97.19.31213.815.2
It PP33.832.230.528.927.325.724.32321.620.519.318.217.416.515.715.114.413.612.711.711.410.69.68
It H------------------------
It NL---------------------9.48.67.1
It EFF30.228.727.225.724.322.921.720.519.318.217.216.215.514.81413.512.912.111.310.510.19.38.46.9
It Deck00.30.610.921.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.63.94.34.655.97.1912.215.617.919.6
Ger PP3735.233.431.629.928.126.625.123.722.421.119.91918.117.216.515.814.813.912.81211.210.28.5
Ger H------------------------
Ger NL---------------------9.99.17.5
Ger EFF3331.429.728.226.625.123.722.421.12018.817.816.916.115.314.714.113.212.411.410.79.88.97.3
Ger Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.63.94.24.54.95.86.98.711.715.117.319
Jp PP42.940.838.736.634.632.630.829.127.52624.523.122212019.118.317.216.114.913.912.911.89.8
Jp H------------------------
Jp NL---------------------11108.3
Jp EFF36.534.632.831.129.427.726.224.723.32220.819.618.717.81716.315.514.613.712.611.810.99.88.1
Jp Deck00.270.550.831.11.31.61.92.22.52.733.33.63.94.24.55.36.37.710.213.115.116.6
Descent00.911.82.73.64.65.97.28.510.211.913.615.81820.222.725.229.233.237.241.245.750.255.3
Velocity278926912593249523972299221621332050198019101840179417481702167416461626160615861598161816381662

320毫米/44倍经 M1934,M1936型火炮,发射穿甲弹,射弹全重1,157磅,弹体重1,018磅;最大射程32,152码。

Range02468101214161820222426283032
Br PP28.82725.323.62220.419.117.916.715.614.713.81312.311.710.89.9
Br H-----------------
Br NL-----------------
Br EFF25.724.122.621.119.618.217.11614.913.913.112.311.61110.49.68.8
Br Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.13.53.94.45.67.7
US PP30.728.826.925.123.421.820.419.117.816.615.614.713.813.112.511.510.6
US H-----------------
US NL-----------------
US EFF27.325.72422.420.919.418.21715.914.813.913.112.311.711.110.29.4
US Deck00.290.580.871.11.41.722.32.62.93.13.53.94.45.67.7
It PP27.325.62422.420.819.318.11715.814.813.913.112.311.911.110.49.6
It H-----------------
It NL----------------8.6
It EFF24.322.821.419.918.617.216.215.114.113.212.411.71110.69.99.38.5
It Deck00.320.640.961.21.61.92.22.52.83.23.53.84.456.49.1
Ger PP29.327.525.72422.420.819.418.21715.914.91413.212.511.910.910.1
Ger H-----------------
Ger NL-----------------
Ger EFF26.124.522.921.419.918.517.316.215.214.113.312.511.811.210.69.79.1
Ger Deck00.320.640.961.21.61.92.22.52.83.23.53.84.34.96.28.9
Jp PP34.232.1302826.124.322.721.319.918.617.416.415.414.713.912.811.8
Jp H-----------------
Jp NL-----------------
Jp EFF2927.325.523.822.220.619.318.116.915.814.813.913.112.411.810.910
Jp Deck00.30.60.91.21.51.82.12.42.733.33.64.14.75.98.2
Descent01.32.645.36.78.91113.215.517.62124.127.430.635.640.6
Velocity27232609249523812267215320721991191018311760171416681649163016111622

请注意:意大利320毫米/44倍经 M1934型火炮,实际应为43.75倍经。另外该炮的弹道数据疑似有误,其发射的是高速重弹,远距离落角不应有那么大。

本表中各国火炮所表现出的特性:

1)本表中美国火炮的穿深数据,非常明显的体现出了炮弹的重要性。同样一种火炮,发射不同的炮弹时,穿深数据居然会有如此显著的差异。
2)本表中日本火炮的穿深数据,表现出普遍疲软的态势,这或许与日本炮弹的性能不尽如人意有关。
3)本表中英国火炮的穿深数据,我个人认为可信度很高。英国新式14寸再差劲,也不该比美国老式14寸火炮还差许多。而这个表中,英国新式14寸的穿深,是全面超越美国老式14寸的。
4)本表中德国火炮的穿深数据,较为合理得还原了德国火炮的实际性能。
5)本表中法国火炮的穿深数据,M1931的情况,我原先所了解的情况大致相符,但M1935则有较大偏差,在其使用法制炮弹与美制炮弹时,弹道特性区别相当大,这可能是计算时输入的数据有误导致的。
6)本表中意大利火炮的穿深数据,表现的相当抢眼,381毫米M1935甚至超越了换弹前的美国16英寸Mark 7。

对于一些异议的解释:

1)同一门火炮使用不同的炮弹,产生的穿深数据可能会有很大程度的浮动,例如美国16寸Mark 7,换弹前威力较弱,甚至弱于部分15寸炮,但换弹后则直接跃升至第一位。
2)英国15英寸/42倍经 Mark I,随着炮弹的更新换代,穿深也有了显著增长。
3)美国超重弹(16寸级别为2,700磅)在近距离的穿深并不如标准弹重(16寸级别为2,240磅)的炮弹,但在远距离上则有显著优势。
3)关于英国15英寸/42倍经 Mark I,在近距离上部分超越美国16英寸/50倍经 Mark 7使用老弹的情况,其实很好理解。美国超重弹在近距离上的穿深确实不出众,同样是使用老弹,16英寸/50倍经 Mark 7甚至还不如16英寸/45倍经 Mark 5,Mark 8。而16英寸Mark 5,Mark 8,与科罗拉多级最初装备的Mark 1,火炮本身是大体相同的。英国凭借其数百年海上霸主的积累,以其15寸炮超越美国差不多同期的16寸炮(指科罗拉多级的16英寸/45倍经 Mark 1,Mark 5,Mark 8),也是可以理解的。
4)日本火炮的表现较为疲软,尤其是46厘米/45倍经 94式火炮的穿深表现,尚不如发射新弹的美国16英寸/50倍经 Mark 7,这是由于日本火炮的有效穿透极限/海军穿透极限数据差距较大造成的。以较为简单的语言描述,则是日本炮弹在面对厚度超过一个临界值的装甲时,很有可能穿而不一定炸。如果单纯以海军穿透极限数据来做比较,则94式依然是穿深最大的战列舰火炮。
5)关于不同口径火炮穿深的比较,各位可以观察美国12英寸Mark 8(305毫米),意大利320毫米M1934,法国330毫米M1931,英国14英寸Mark VII(356毫米),这一系列不同口径火炮的穿深表现。除法国330毫米M1931外,大体呈现出口径越大,穿深越大的趋势,这是符合常理的。

疑点:

1)法国M1935的穿深数据,法制炮弹与美制炮弹的表现差异较大,疑似是计算时输入的弹道数据有误导致的。
2)德国40.6厘米 SK C/34的穿深,部分情况下反而不如38厘米 SK C/34,该数据存疑,疑似是计算时输入的炮弹数据有误导致的。
3)意大利320毫米/44倍经 M1934型火炮,远距离上的水平穿深数值过大,疑似是计算时输入的弹道数据有误导致的。
回复

使用道具 举报

中将

五年服役纪念章一级铁十字勋章元老荣誉纪念章行政立法委旗手终身荣誉会员

发表于 2013-1-11 08:42:11 | 显示全部楼层
要说意大利装甲胜过英国装甲,在没有其它资料的前提下我不怀疑这个结论。
但要说M1934穿深超过94,我承认这毁了我的价值观

还有,M1934对英国装甲、意大利装甲的穿深表现超过94,而对美国装甲、德国装甲和日本装甲则不如94.
难不成炮弹和装甲也有属性相生相克?
回复

使用道具 举报

少校

五年服役纪念章旗手

发表于 2013-1-11 09:02:57 | 显示全部楼层
我靠,面条这么威武??话说法国的装甲和火炮怎么样啊。各大列强都有了就没香水的,香水也太没存在感了--!
回复

使用道具 举报

上士

四年服役纪念章

发表于 2013-1-11 09:45:52 | 显示全部楼层
亮瞎双眼 难以置信
回复

使用道具 举报

上士

四年服役纪念章

发表于 2013-1-11 09:48:53 | 显示全部楼层
yxwd5 发表于 2013-1-11 09:02
我靠,面条这么威武??话说法国的装甲和火炮怎么样啊。各大列强都有了就没香水的,香水也太没存在感了--! ...

香水的装甲和动力系统几乎没见人说起过啊
回复

使用道具 举报

一等兵

四年服役纪念章

发表于 2013-1-11 10:06:26 | 显示全部楼层
意大利的炮猛,装甲强,水面舰队战绩却……那是不是说明水兵素质很……
回复

使用道具 举报

中将

五年服役纪念章一级铁十字勋章元老荣誉纪念章行政立法委旗手终身荣誉会员

发表于 2013-1-11 10:17:28 | 显示全部楼层
本帖最后由 克虏伯火炮 于 2013-1-11 10:18 编辑
yxwd5 发表于 2013-1-11 09:02
我靠,面条这么威武??话说法国的装甲和火炮怎么样啊。各大列强都有了就没香水的,香水也太没存在感了--! ...


对法国装甲,欧肯给的评价比较高,说从1912年添加了钼元素,改善制造过程,是一战期间最好的装甲。
二战期间的评价也不错,似乎是说成分接近于德国的KC n/A,而硬化深度则是35%——在欧肯看来这是最合适的硬化深度了。
但欧肯也说,法国装甲资料很少。恐怕这也是猜测而已。

NOTES ON 20th-CENTURY FRENCH NAVAL ARMOR:

. . . . My knowledge of French naval armor is very limited, but I know that it introduced many of the basic metallurgical improvements used by armor and construction steel during the 19th and early 20th Centuries. The following are some information that I know of concerning French naval armor in the 20th Century:

. . . . 1) France introduced Molybdenum in 1912 to improve the manufacturing process for naval armor by increasing the hardenability and toughness of the steel and by making the metal tougher when in its high-temperature solid austenite form. This indicates to me that French World War I-era armor was the equal to the best foreign armor, at least in standard manufacturing processes, steel quality, and so forth.

. . . . 2) French naval designers decided during the 1930's that steeply-falling armor-piercing aircraft bombs would be more of a threat than more shallow impacts by medium-to-long-range naval gun projectiles and they therefore had face-hardened armor used for all plates over 4" (10.2cm) on turret and conning tower roofs where layered protection (spaced decks) was not possible. To my knowledge, no other nation did this. Ironically, while this idea turned out to be absolutely true in almost every case in World War II, the one case where a French main turret roof--a 5.91" (15cm) roof plate on the battle-cruiser DUNKERQUE--was hit was not by an aircraft bomb, but by a 15" (38.1cm) 1938-pound hard-capped armor-piercing projectile at about 70-75o obliquity fired by the HMS HOOD at close range. The projectile broke in half and the nose ricocheted off, but the projectile lower body did not ricochet and the plate ended up with a large, projectile-shaped hole in it (it actually seems to be an outline of the British projectile on its side pushed into the plate!), throwing a large amount of plate material into the turret at high velocity, followed by the lower portion of the projectile, which then exploded (probably a less-than-full-strength explosion, but what difference did it make?) inside the turret, knocking out the right half of the split 4-gun mount (each turret was divided by heavy internal armored bulkheads into two adjacent 2-gun turrets on one mount, a unique French design). If the armor had been homogeneous, the projectile would have ricocheted off in one piece and probably no armor would have been ejected from the plate hit.

. . . . 3) French World War II-era armor test results (I have a couple) give their face-hardened armor a perfect fit (my formulae give the exact (!!) complete penetration velocities found in the tests) for an armor of the best World War II-era plate quality using the 35% face of original German KC armor (i.e., Krupp World War II KC n/A with a Krupp World War I-era KC a/A face depth).

. . . . 4) In 1938-39 an experimental 5.91" (15cm) KC-type plate was manufactured that was standard except that it had been "baked" in the cementing oven for an entire year (!!). After the fall of France in 1940, the Germans took this plate back to Krupp where it was found to give unusual (I bet!) ballistic performance. Does anyone know more about this plate?

回复

使用道具 举报

中将

五年服役纪念章一级铁十字勋章元老荣誉纪念章行政立法委旗手终身荣誉会员

发表于 2013-1-11 10:31:17 | 显示全部楼层
本帖最后由 克虏伯火炮 于 2013-1-11 10:54 编辑

但有一种说法是,各种装甲的相对效能与厚度有关,180毫米以下是Class A最好、220-350毫米KC n/A最好、350以上1935CA最好。
结合Class A的硬化比例最大、达到55%左右,KC n/A硬化比例较大、通常40-50%,1935CA则较小,通常30-35%的实际情况,以及硬化层/基材各自在穿甲过程中所起到的物理作用来看,我认为硬化深度也不是35%就最好,而应该是板厚越小,硬化比例就越大一点,要保证有一定硬化层的绝对厚度才对。
回复

使用道具 举报

少尉

五年服役纪念章铜星勋章政道纪念章

发表于 2013-1-11 10:59:12 | 显示全部楼层
克虏伯火炮 发表于 2013-1-11 10:31
但有一种说法是,各种装甲的相对效能与厚度有关,180毫米以下是Class A最好、220-350毫米KC n/A最好、350以 ...

400以上貌似是VH?
回复

使用道具 举报

中将

五年服役纪念章一级铁十字勋章元老荣誉纪念章行政立法委旗手终身荣誉会员

发表于 2013-1-11 11:08:52 | 显示全部楼层
本帖最后由 克虏伯火炮 于 2013-1-11 12:23 编辑
a5mg4n 发表于 2013-1-11 10:59
400以上貌似是VH?


确实看过这种说法。
另外还有410毫米VH优于420毫米KC。关于后一个你有更详细的资料吗?

PS.从上述计算表格中,远距离上恰好是16寸板厚级别的,但也没有体现出VH优于Class A啊,纠结中......
回复

使用道具 举报

中将

五年服役纪念章一级铁十字勋章元老荣誉纪念章行政立法委旗手终身荣誉会员

发表于 2013-1-11 13:28:18 | 显示全部楼层
本帖最后由 克虏伯火炮 于 2013-1-11 13:31 编辑

我提一点质疑观点:
德国火炮穿甲能力,在炮口处 16”/52竟然不及 15”/52
http://www.zhanliejian.com/navweaps/Penetration_Germany.htm
二者速度接近,又是同一个国家造的,所以应该排除速度和弹体差异带来的影响。
那么就看比动能吧,怎么也该是16寸强于15寸啊。
我无法理解。
回复

使用道具 举报

中将

四年服役纪念章钻石金双剑金橡叶铁十字勋章荣誉勋章维多利亚十字勋章行政立法委骑士团勋章海武魂旗手TIME TRAVELER终身荣誉会员

 楼主| 发表于 2013-1-11 13:38:48 | 显示全部楼层
克虏伯火炮 发表于 2013-1-11 13:28
我提一点质疑观点:
德国火炮穿甲能力,在炮口处 16”/52竟然不及 15”/52
http://www.zhanliejian.com/nav ...


对,他算的这个表确实有这种倾向,各国16寸炮的穿深,往往还不如15寸炮。甚至94式的数据有时还不如M1934

但如果在15寸炮间进行横向比较,我认为还是比较有参考性的

如果将表中各国15寸火炮进行横向比较,可以得出一个明显且易于被多数人接受的结论

穿深:意大利M1934>法国M1935>德国 SK C/34>英国15寸马克1(强装药)
回复

使用道具 举报

上尉

五年服役纪念章

发表于 2013-1-11 13:52:25 | 显示全部楼层
seven_nana 发表于 2013-1-11 13:38
对,他算的这个表确实有这种倾向,各国16寸炮的穿深,往往还不如15寸炮。甚至94式的数据有时还不如M1934
...

Italian  15”/50 gun, 1,951-lb shell with 1,717-lb body weight; maximum range is 46,219  yards.                       
Range        0        2        4        6        8        10        12        14        16        18        20        22        24        26        28        30        32
Br EFF        31.9        30.3        28.7        27.2        25.7        24.2        22.9        21.6        20.4        19.3        18.2        17.2        16.4        15.6        14.8        14.2        13.6
US EFF        35.6        33.9        32.1        30.4        28.7        27.1        25.6        24.2        22.8        21.6        20.3        19.2        18.3        17.4        16.6        15.9        15.2
It EFF        30.2        28.7        27.2        25.7        24.3        22.9        21.7        20.5        19.3        18.2        17.2        16.2        15.5        14.8        14        13.5        12.9
Ger EFF        33        31.4        29.7        28.2        26.6        25.1        23.7        22.4        21.1        20        18.8        17.8        16.9        16.1        15.3        14.7        14.1
Jp EFF        36.5        34.6        32.8        31.1        29.4        27.7        26.2        24.7        23.3        22        20.8        19.6        18.7        17.8        17        16.3        15.5
Descent°        0        0.91        1.8        2.7        3.6        4.6        5.9        7.2        8.5        10.2        11.9        13.6        15.8        18        20.2        22.7        25.2



French 15”/45 gun, the original French  1,949-lb shell with 1,715-lb body weight; maximum range is 45,600 yards.
Range        0        2        4        6        8        10        12        14        16        18        20        22        24        26        28        30        32
Br EFF        32.9        31        29.1        26.9        25        23.2        21.7        20.3        18.8        17.3        16.3        15.2        14.2        13.4        12.6        11.9        11.4
US EFF        36.8        34.6        32.6        30        27.7        25.7        23.9        22.3        20.6        18.9        17.7        16.5        15.3        14.4        13.5        12.7        12.1
It EFF        31.1        29.3        27.6        25.5        23.7        22        20.5        19.2        17.8        16.4        15.4        14.4        13.5        12.7        11.9        11.3        10.7
Ger EFF        34.1        32.1        30.2        27.9        25.8        23.9        22.3        20.9        19.3        17.8        16.7        15.6        14.5        13.7        12.8        12.2        11.6
Jp EFF        37.6        36.4        33.3        30.8        28.6        26.5        24.7        23.1        21.4        19.7        18.5        17.3        16.2        15.2        14.3        13.5        12.9
Descent°        0        0.79        1.6        2.8        4        5.4        6.7        8.2        10.1        12.4        14.4        16.9        19.7        22.5        25.7        28.7        31.6

你引用的表格里,法国炮的威力超过意大利炮啊。
【该用户ID已经被回收】
回复

使用道具 举报

中将

五年服役纪念章一级铁十字勋章元老荣誉纪念章行政立法委旗手终身荣誉会员

发表于 2013-1-11 13:54:38 | 显示全部楼层
本帖最后由 克虏伯火炮 于 2013-1-11 13:56 编辑
seven_nana 发表于 2013-1-11 13:38
对,他算的这个表确实有这种倾向,各国16寸炮的穿深,往往还不如15寸炮。甚至94式的数据有时还不如M1934
...


PP极限(Partial Penetration ),就是前半部分刺入后半部分卡住的状态,意大利1934能够比法国1935对付稍微厚一点的装甲,而穿透极限,则是法国1935略强于意大利1934。
这虽然与两者动能大小相反,但还可以用“两者炮弹结构设计和特点不同”来勉强理解。
但16寸不如15寸,与常识不符。各国不会傻到花钱造性能反而降低了的炮啊。

另,其实没有证据可以证明法国炮弹强于意大利的,反而法国原厂炮弹有缺陷。
到了美国之后打的一直是美国炮弹,而美国在那个时候的炮弹性能则是落后的。
所以法国炮更不应该比意大利的强了。
回复

使用道具 举报

中将

四年服役纪念章钻石金双剑金橡叶铁十字勋章荣誉勋章维多利亚十字勋章行政立法委骑士团勋章海武魂旗手TIME TRAVELER终身荣誉会员

 楼主| 发表于 2013-1-11 13:56:47 | 显示全部楼层
动感炮神 发表于 2013-1-11 13:52
Italian  15”/50 gun, 1,951-lb shell with 1,717-lb body weight; maximum range is 46,219  yards.                         ...

意大利炮大约从6千码开始,穿深就大于法国炮了
回复

使用道具 举报

上尉

五年服役纪念章

发表于 2013-1-11 14:00:10 | 显示全部楼层
本帖最后由 动感炮神 于 2013-1-11 14:05 编辑
克虏伯火炮 发表于 2013-1-11 13:54
PP极限(Partial Penetration ),就是前半部分刺入后半部分卡住的状态,意大利1934能够比法国1935对付稍 ...


毒气毁一生,炸膛穷三代。另外,会不会试验样炮弹头没有毒气室?不然应该试验就炸膛吧……
【该用户ID已经被回收】
回复

使用道具 举报

上尉

五年服役纪念章

发表于 2013-1-11 14:00:28 | 显示全部楼层
seven_nana 发表于 2013-1-11 13:56
意大利炮大约从6千码开始,穿深就大于法国炮了

我瞎了。
【该用户ID已经被回收】
回复

使用道具 举报

中将

四年服役纪念章钻石金双剑金橡叶铁十字勋章荣誉勋章维多利亚十字勋章行政立法委骑士团勋章海武魂旗手TIME TRAVELER终身荣誉会员

 楼主| 发表于 2013-1-11 14:00:56 | 显示全部楼层
本帖最后由 seven_nana 于 2013-3-12 02:42 编辑
克虏伯火炮 发表于 2013-1-11 13:54
PP极限(Partial Penetration ),就是前半部分刺入后半部分卡住的状态,意大利1934能够比法国1935对付稍 ...


PP = Partial Penetration - 部分穿透。对于入射倾角小于45度的情况而言,若射弹前半段侵入了装甲,而后半段未能完成穿透,则称为部分穿透。对于入射倾角大于45度的情况而言,若弹尖与上半段弹体未能完成穿透,而残余的下半段弹体侵入了装甲,则称为部分穿透。在部分穿透的情况下,射弹通常不会爆炸,或发生低爆速爆炸,但仍会对装甲板后方的人或物造成破片伤害。

H = Holing Limit - 穿孔极限。特定穿甲弹射击表面硬化装甲时,在能够造成破坏的前提下,所能对抗的最大厚度的装甲。在这种情况下,射弹本身并不会穿透装甲,但会有一块装甲碎块被挤入舰体。碎块的尺寸通常与射弹直径相近。

NL = Naval Limit - 海军穿透极限。在80%的射弹能够确保穿透的前提下,所能对抗的最大厚度的装甲。在这种情况下,射弹通常已经破损,且很有可能不会爆炸,但仍会对装甲板后方的人或物造成破片伤害。

EFF = Effective Limit - 有效穿透极限。在射弹能够有效穿透,且弹体大致无损能够正常爆炸的前提下,所能对抗的最大厚度的装甲。

上述是Tony DiGiulian写的,与Nathan Okun描述略有不同,但核心概念上没有出入与争议
回复

使用道具 举报

少校

六年服役纪念章全球架空纪念章终身荣誉会员

发表于 2013-1-11 14:02:50 | 显示全部楼层
偶有个问题,装甲板可否采用冷锻方式,众所周知,冷锻出来的东西,相当结实,但是缺点就是太费时费力,但是考虑到战列舰的数量稀少性,采用冷锻装甲作为其主装甲,似乎不存在产能不足的问题吧。
史司:你傻逼
刘芷:你脑残
.....(两个小时后)
史司:你傻逼
刘芷:你脑残
....
————————摘自中华共和国海军造舰局《新型战列舰设计方案讨论会》
回复

使用道具 举报

上尉

五年服役纪念章

发表于 2013-1-11 14:03:39 | 显示全部楼层
风之旋律 发表于 2013-1-11 14:02
偶有个问题,装甲板可否采用冷锻方式,众所周知,冷锻出来的东西,相当结实,但是缺点就是太费时费力,但是 ...


战列舰数量不多,可是每条战列舰需要的装甲可不少。冷锻的话,大概“十年磨一舰”吧……
【该用户ID已经被回收】
回复

使用道具 举报

手机版|Archiver|© 2010-2018 zhanliejian.com, All Rights Reserved ( 沪ICP备13004737号

GMT+8, 2019-4-21 14:40 , Processed in 0.323713 second(s), 12 queries , File On.

Powered by Discuz! X3.3

© 2001-2017 Comsenz Inc.

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表